Mormon Classics   |   Spalding Library   |   Bookshelf   |   Newspapers   |   History Vault


Part 1   Part 2   Part 3

1841 Samuel Williams text   |   1886 Samuel Williams letter   |   1913 1st Baptist Centenary
1925 1st Baptist Church Hist.   |   1939 Hist. Pittsburgh Churches   |   1948 Peters Cr. Church Hist.
1998 Peters Cr. Church Hist.   |   1882 Washington Co. history   |   more Washington Co. histories
Rigdon Chronology (extracts)   |   Allegheny Co. Histories (extracts)   |   text files   |   Rigdon in OH

Reply to Lectures on
Christian Baptism

by Rev. Samuel Williams
(Cincinnati: Moore & Anderson, 1853)

  • Preface to the 1st ed.

  • biographical sketch (1913)

  • transcriber's notes

  • iii

    P R E F A C E


    To the members of the First Baptist Church of Jesus Christ, of Pittsburgh.


    Fourteen years ago [May 1827]; I was called in the Providence of God, to the care of your souls. At that time you were few in number, feeble in resources, and like your brethren in the days of Paul, "a sect every where spoken against." Immediately after my connection with you in the pastoral relation, I was called upon to maintain the cause of truth against fearful forms of error.

    On various occasions, I have opposed through the press, the doctrine of Rantismal Salvation. A doctrine, while it mutilates the scheme of "salvation by grace," utterly sets aside the authority of Christ as Lawgiver in Zion, and wherever it prevails, entirely supercedes the ordinance of Christian Baptism. It also destroys the distinction God has made between the church and the world. Hence, in all countries where the Romish church is established, and in some Protestant provinces, all children are christened by Rantism, -- all of the inhabitants are members of the church, though they may be infidels in sentiment, and more degraded than heathen in morals; and consequently, pure primitive Christianity, both in spirit and form, is almost wholly unknown to them.

    With what ability I have opposed those errors, I leave you to judge. Of one thing I am certain, that is, that God has unequivocally given us the seal of his approbation, in the fact, that he has increased our number from twenty-seven, to more than four hundred, notwithstanding several churches have been organized of members dismissed from us for that purpose.

    While we continue to strive together for the faith and practice of the gospel in the strength of the Lord, let us also cultivate those graces which adorn the christian character -- at once the fruits of the Spirit, and a sure pledge of joys to come. Especially,


    would I exhirt you to pray with, and for your children, and instruct them in the knowledge of eternal truth, at home and in the Sabbath School. Not from the consideration that the Jews were circumcised, nor from that of vows made at the shrine of the Man of sin, do I thus exhort you, but from the consideration that they are yours by a Divine constitution, and because the Sporit has expressly commanded you to "Bring up your children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord."...

    For the author of the "Lectures" to which I reply, I have no other feelings than those of respect and kindness.

    No considerations, however, can justify the palliation of error, nor apologize for lack of zeal or courage in the maintenance of the "truth as it is in Jesus."

    To contribute something towards the victories which Christ will achieve over the kingdom of darkness, these pages were prepared, and are now presented to you in token of my affectionate regard for your welfare, accompanied with my fervent prayer, that in the cause of our Master you may prove "faithful even unto death."

                              Respectfully, your Pastor,
                                                         SAMUEL WILLIAMS.
    PITTSBURGH, May 1, 1841.

    Note 1: Elder Samuel Williams' Reply to Lectures on... Christian Baptism provides very little information on the Baptist congregation he was serving in Pittsburgh, but his 1841 Preface does give some indication of his circumstances a year before he published his next, more historically substantial volume, Mormonism Exposed. See the transciber's notes notes appended to that on-line text for more information on Elder Williams

    Note 2: A series of three letters written by Williams to James T. Cobb in 1878 provide some additional information regarding Sidney Rigdon, the Pittsburgh Baptist church, etc.

    Centenary of... Baptist
    Work in... Pittsburgh

    (Pittsburgh: Pitts. Baptist Assoc., 1913)

  • "Baptist Controversies of 1800s"
  •         Campbellites
            Anti-Mission Baptists
  • Early Baptist Ministers
  • Peters Creek Church
  • 1913 Historical Exhibit

  • [ 56 ]


    By David Spencer, D. D., pastor Lehigh Avenue Church, Philadelphia.

    The Century from 1812 to 1912, inclusive, was probably one of the most controversial in the history of Christianity.

    Through your kindly invitation I am to speak on "The Baptist Controversies" of the last hundred years, a period which signalizes the organic life of the Baptists of Pittsburgh. I am not to speak on this topic controversially, but from the position of history and fact.

    This subject becomes a very timely one in connection with your Centennial Celebration, because some of these controversies had their beginning right here in this vicinity. It is not a waste of time if we recall, even briefly, these controversies. In some respects they are to be regretted, as they have engendered strife, divisions and some of the worst evils which threaten our country today. In other ways, they have been tributary to a better understanding of truth and of each other. They have illustrated human nature very forcefully, and have shown the great need of Divine Grace, the guidance of the Holy Spirit as well as good common sense and honesty of soul, in order to reach the truth in our religious faith and practice.


    It was on June 12, 1812, that Thomas and Alexander Campbell, father and son, of the Presbyterian Church, were immersed on profession of their faith in Christ, in Buffalo Creek, by Elder Luce, and received into the Brush Run Baptist Church. Gradually they came to entertain strenuous views on the subject of baptism, that regeneration is not complete until the

    [ 57 ]

    believer obeys Christ in the act of baptism, making baptism essential to the completeness of salvation. Because of these differences, the positive and unyielding character of Alexander Campbell and other causes, the chasm between the parties was broadened, leading up to the separation, after some of the most bitter discussions on either side.

    The Baptists, in all this region, at that time were hyper-Calvinistic, while our ministers as a rule were not up with Alexander Campbell, in culture and influence. Our churches suffered as a result and, by 1827, the real separation took place, spreading rapidly all over the country. It is not the object of this paper to enter into the discussions connected with and emanating from the establishment of this sister denomination. The differences are not so pronounced as in the earlier years of the century. A better understanding of the Scriptures and of each other, as well as a fuller indwelling of the Holy Spirit, are drawing us closer together, and, in some parts of our country, we are actually getting together. The Disciples, today, number a membership of one and a half millions. The Lord grant the day may soon come when they and we may be one, even as the Father and Christ are one.


    There seems to be sufficient evidence extant to prove that Sidney Rigdon had as much to do in the preparation and palming off of what is now known as "The Book of Mormon" as any other man. He was once the pastor of the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh. When a young man he was ordained as a Baptist minister. However, in the basis of his character, he lacked moral honesty and principle. He was a sharp and shrewd manipulator for the advancement of selfish ambitious. He soon manifested a flagrant

    [ 58 ]

    erroneousness of doctrine, preaching a baptismal regeneration, even more advanced than Alexander Campbell, and advocating a community of ownership in all things belonging to the members of the church, as well as other false dogmas. He was deposed from our ministry and excluded from our denomination. Getting hold of the document by Spaulding, entitled, "The Lost Manuscript," Rigdon conceived the idea of founding a new religion based on pretended revelations. He accordingly set to work to revise this manuscript and so adapt it to his purpose as to warrant its acceptance as the "Bible" of the new faith.

    Having some knowledge of the art of printing and stereotyping, and having access on the quiet to the Patterson Printing office in Pittsburgh, he was able to complete the collusion.

    Requiring some one more bold in the art of deception and sin, this excommunicated Baptist imposter repaired to Manchester, N. Y., where he found the desired co-operator, Joseph Smith. Gold plates of this Religious Novel were stereotyped. These were secreted away and then hunted for by the gross deceivers, who professed to have a revelation from heaven. When found they were called the "Golden Bible," or "The Book of Mormon." Thus, based upon this diabolical imposition, originating in the disordered brain of a once Baptist minister in our own Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, has been built up one of the darkest infamies that blackens the escutcheon and endangers the life of our Republic to-day. Mormonism is not, of course, the topic of our paper. In fact it is not a Christian religion, but in view of Sidney Rigdon's connection with it, it certainly has a place in the Baptist Controversies of the century.

    Said Dwight L. Moody, at the close of his meetings in Salt Lake City, "The Baptists are the only people

    [ 59 ]

    who can do anything with the Mormons." In view of this fact it might well become one of the controversies throughout this land in which the Baptists might well take an aggressive and enlightening part


    With the beginning of the 19th century, the spirit of revival permeated our country. With the formation of the Republic, the separation of Church and State and the prevalence of Religious Liberty, there was a cutting loose from stereotyped creeds and a taking of the Bible as interpreted by all for themselves, as the personal standard of faith and practice. Hence in many parts of the country there were those who set up for themselves independent churches. The New Testament phrase, "The disciples were first called Christians at Antioch," furnished a very convenient Biblical title for these independent bodies to assume. With the progress of years these churches affiliated into an organization whose name was at first pronounced Christ-ians. They were strongly Arminian in doctrine and in some directions Arian, relative to the absolute Deity of Christ. They practise immersion but do not always make it a term of church membership. This movement was not quite so radical as that led by Alexander Campbell, and yet, in many particulars, in some places, there is a striking resemblance between them and the Disciples.

    Born during the last century, in many communities of our state, the controversy has waged between them and the so-called regulars, yet in reality, when you get right down to the rock bottom of their faith, practice and fellowship, they and the regulars are not so very far apart. In some places they are actually affiliating with us, and our churches are being merged together. After the controversies of the past century

    [ 60 ]

    it begins to look as if early in the present one there might be a coming together under the one motto of "one Lord, one faith and one baptism." Their membership at present is about 87,000.


    In the great discussion between God's sovereignty and man's free agency, Calvinism and Arminianism, Free and Strict Communion, and, specially among Baptists, Gillism and Fullerism, as it was then called, this branch of the Baptist family had its origin. The term Freewill, was first given derisively from the outside, but soon it was the adopted name, and remained so until a few years ago, when the term "Will" was dropped and the name "Free Baptist" was assumed, but the Spirit of the Lord, education and missions have so far advanced that already the getting together under one banner has made wonderful progress. Identified with this body, as with all the other Baptist bodies of which I have spoken, or am to speak, are a host of noble men and women. As we have had opportunity of mingling with these and getting into their hearts as well as ntinds, all thoughts of the differences and controversies of former years have disappeared, and to my knowledge there has been an interchanging of letters among their churches and our own.

    Their first General Conference was held in 1827. In 1882 one of their great educational institutions sought a Regular Baptist as the head of the college, actuated by a desire that it might be a step toward the combination of the entire Baptist family. The proposal was not accepted because the party felt inadequate to the presidency, though he had no doubt that his duty was in the pastorate. The acidity of early controversies has passed away. A better understanding

    [ 61 ]

    of each other in faith and practice has brought us very near to each other. In fact in some places we are one to all intents and purposes. Free Baptists today number over 70,000, but the time seems to be ripe for a coalition with us without any loss to us but with great gain to them.


    In some parts these were called German Baptists. They practice Trine Immersion, Feet-Washing, Love-Feasts, the Kiss of Charity and insist upon the greatest simplicity in dress. While the elder people are resisting any innovation, a strong progressive element is seeking to minimize the peculiarities which have distinguished them. Their young people come into our churches and become much at home with us. The late Dr. George Groff, an honored professor of Bucknell University, was very anxious that a movement be made to get them and the regulars together. He was positive that a little overture, recognition and kindness on our part would meet with good results.

    Out of the controversies of the centuries have come light, a clearer knowledge of truth and a better apprehension on their real relation to those outside of their limited views. Their membership to-day is over 300,000.


    This denomination had its origin with John Winnebrenner in 1830, in and around Harrisburg, our State Capitol. Its people were called, in the early days, "Winnebrennarians," after the founder who was a German Reformed minister. They practice only the immersion of believers. They are very strong on the sufficiency of the Bible without note or interpretation by the commentators. Their members come into connection

    [ 62 ]

    with us and are at home in our churches. In many respects the creed of this denomination is the same as a Baptist Confession of Faith. In the early days of our Baptist efforts in Harrisburg, this denomination, which had a good start there and seemed in reality to be Baptistic, was one of the obstacles. Of this I have often heard Rev. David Williams, one of our pioneers in our work there, speak. This organization, the Church of God, has a membership of over 40,000, and I believe they would all make good regular Baptists. At least, that has been my experience with those whom I have known.


    The churches of this order organized into Associations in 1835. They are distinguished from us mainly by their views on the Sabbath. They believe that the seventh day of the week, and not the first, ought to be observed as the Sabbath of the Lord. When, however, members of these churches move into communities where only the Regular Baptist Churches are to be found, letters from the Seventh Day bodies are granted to unite with those observing the first day of the week. In revival efforts, these churches and their ministers heartily unite in service with those who observe the first day of the week. Their type of thought relative to the seventh day is distinctly judaizing. We firmly believe that a little good Baptist controversy, full of the Christ spirit, would go a long way towards bringing them and us together upon a common platform. They have a membership in this country of about 9,000.


    Mennonites agree with Baptists in rejecting Infant Baptism, but the large majority of them practice pouring as the act of baptism, though they will immerse if

    [ 63 ]

    it is insisted on. Menno Simon, their founder, was a decided Ana-Baptist, though probably not an out and out Baptist. They are not really Baptist, yet a little missionary work, prompted and carried on in the spirit of Christian love, would go a long way towards settling this matter and make us of one Lord, one faith and one baptism. When they do become Baptists, they make good ones. Some of them are really that now except in name. Their membership is about 55,000.


    It was in 1814 that our American Baptist Foreign Missionary Society was organized in Philadelphia. At once there was a growing opposition to missionary societies as well as all kinds of human institutions, as they were called. Our people, many of them, were up in arms against these new departures. It was under these conditions that the Redstone Association, in this part of our state, organized in 1776, became an "Old School" body, absorbing into its membership the Baptist Churches hereabout, which were ultra Calvinistic in doctrine and against human agency in service. Their thought was that if God wanted the heathen converted He would do it without our aid.

    As a counteracting force to this anti-mission spirit, the Monongahela Association was organized as a missionary body in 1832. In this the churches, possessed of the missionary and, therefore, the true Gospel idea, formed congenial fellowship. Seven years afterward, in 1839, the Pittsburgh Association, embracing the churches of this city and vicinity, was organized. This body has always stood four square on the Big Four lines of all true Christian church work and worship, as represented in Bible School endeavor, missionary activity, prayer-meeting service and a preached Gospel. As to the contrast to-day between the "Old

    [ 64 ]

    School" position and that of our own obedient churches, comment is unnecessary. Today they call themselves Primitive Baptists and number, throughout the country, white and colored, about 137,000, priding themselves on that passage of Scripture which says "Fear not, little flock, it is your Father's good pleasure to give you the kingdom."


    It was in 1815 that the First Baptist Sunday School of Philadelphia was organized. Three Christian women conceived the idea of gathering the children on the Lord's day for Bible reading and religious instruction. One brother said to them, whose counsel they sought, "he did not like the idea of congregating children in a mass and exhibiting them on the Lord's day to be gazed at as paupers." At this day such advice seems to be astounding. These sisters, undaunted, then called on their pastor, Henry Holcombe, D. D. His reply to their proposal was, "Well, my sisters, you can but try it, blossoms are sweet and beautiful, even if they produce no fruit." After considerable effort they finally secured deacon Joseph Keen to open the school with prayer. He was the grandparent of our distinguished Wm. W. Keen, M. D., so noted in the medical world. What was true in the beginning of the school referred to could be duplicated in the opposition controversies awakened in the early years of the century past relative to Bible school work. Thank God for the glorious position of this work to-day.


    A hundred years ago in Pennsylvania, we had no regular denominational school for higher education and theological training. A pastor here and there, turned his study into a seminary to help some student

    [ 65 ]

    to a better equipment for the Christian ministry. There was discussion and controversy on the subject. This led to the establishment, recognition and help for schools elsewhere. Of the controversy relative to Staughton's Theological School, Haddington College and Germantown Collegiate Institution, all in Philadelphia, early in the century, I need not speak. The great need for an educated ministry became apparent. The help required to aid young men in their preparation for this work was in evidence. This led to the organization, in 1839, of on, Pennsylvania Baptist Education Society, whose grand work in all these years cannot be over-estimated. These all prepared the way for what is now Bucknell University, founded in 1846. Of the cntroversy connected with the discontinuance of the theological department at Lewisburg and the opening of the Croner Theological Seminary at Upland, as well as the discussions leading up to the founding of the other Baptist schools in our Commonwealth, I need not dwell upon it; but to-day these splendidly equipped plants represent a valuation of some four millions of dollars.

    At the beginning of your century of organized work our Baptist educational institutions numbered about five in the entire country, and they were all exceedingly small affairs. After all the education controversies of the century they number to-day about 200, with an equipment valued at over $100,000,000, and a student attendance of over 60,000. Surely we may well exclaim, through the Baptist education controversies of the century "What hath God wrought?" "This is the Lord's doings and it is marvelous in our eyes".


    Organically the date given to the beginning of our State Mission work is 1827, but in reality it is cotemporaneous

    [ 66 ]

    with your own Centennial. It even antedates your own organic life. In the Beaver Association there was an early movement for State Mission work. Even Sidney Rigdon and others were employed as missionaries of the "Philadelphia Baptist Domestic Mission Society" in the state of Ohio and along the western bounday of Pennsylvania in 1815 and in former years. The sacrifices and the controversies of those years were great. In 1880 a strong controversy was on, looking to the doing of City Mission work, as a department of the State work. This was a clear conviction of the then president, Rev. Richard H. Austin. He had been successful in business and was ready with a liberal hand for this line Of work. A new Secretary was chosen in fullest sympathy with this movement. Sacred pledges were given him in every prominent city of the state, that if he took up the work there would be this co-operation between these cities and the state. For reasons, which need not be given here he did not accept. Whether he made a mistake or not the Lord knows. With him there would have been unity throughout the Commonwealth on this question, but another one did accept, and at [once] city organizations, separate from the state, began their career.


    Some may say, O, this was not a Baptist Controversy. O yes, it was. It got into our churches.

    In 1845 it resulted in the organization of the Southern Baptist Convention. In 1858 it was the moving cause leading up to the formation of the North Philadelphia Association in this state. The controversy in the Central Union Association had become so radical on the abolition question, that the more consemative element felt it was time to withdraw which they did...

    (pages 67-97 not transcribed)

    [ 98 ]

    ... Mr. Wood: -- Dr. A. J. Bonsall, Nestor of our Baptist pastors in Western Pennsylvania, will speak to us on the Baptist ministry in the Centenary.

    Dr. Bonsall: -- I do not like to read, but I have to read. I suppose you do not like to listen to reading quite so well, but you have a choice whether to listen or not.


    By Rev. A. J. Bonsall, Litt. D., Pastor of
    Sandusky Street Baptist Churh, Pittsburgh, Pa.

    The Baptists have never been a strong denomination in numbers or wealth in Western Pennsylvania compared with some others, but they have possessed a vigorous life. They hold convictions for which in earlier days they had to contend, and which marked

    [ 99 ]

    them as a peculiar people. The development of religious thought and the growth of ecclesiastical comity have blunted the edge of discussion and softened the asperities of sectarian intercourse. We of this territory cannot boast a monopoly of intellect and eloquence in our Baptist ministry, but we do claim a decent proportion of ability in our pulpits. The withdrawal of Alexander Campbell with a large following, on account of doctrinal differences, made it a serious struggle for our denomination here during a considerable period. War breeds warriors, and these controversies produced men of determination and polemical acuteness. This portion of our state has enjoyed the service and influence of many strong and earnest ministers. It would be a difficult task even to name all the men who have contributed to our history, and quite impossible to present biographical notices of them. Their names are written in the book of remembrance before the throne of God. All that I shall attempt to do is to recall to your attention some of those who labored faithfully and well within the bounds of the present Pittsburgh Association, and whose works do follow them.

    I am dividing them into groups, loosely and arbitrarily both as to the titles of the groups and their members. For I do not wish to recite a mere directory of names, of bare extracts from a cyclopedia.

    The first group is that of Pioneers. They explored and broke ground and sowed seed and also had their joy of a partial harvest. They did considerable fighting, too. They carried on a defensive and offensive war on pedobaptism all the time, and a part of the time they contended for their faith against foes of their own household,

    Of this early group the names that stand out most clearly are those of David Philips, James Estep, John

    [ 100 ]

    Winter, Samuel Williams and William Shadrach. To these men the denomination owes a large debt of gratitude. In the vanguard of our forces they marched with intrepid and unfaltering step. They left the impress of their personality upon the societies they gathered and formed. We are far from them in time, and, in many respects, in dogma; but it is to be hoped that we are closely related to them in spirit.

    David Philips came to America from Wales in 1758, He and three brothers received commissions in Washington's army. They raised a company and officered it. After the war of Independence, probably in 1780, he removed to Library, Pa. He served as judge of an election held in 1799. In the assessment roll for 1784 he is mentioned as "Preacher David Philips" to distinguish him from Colonel David Philips, another resident. He was ordained in May of the year 1781. He became the second pastor of the Peters Creek Church, and gave a lot for the erection of a church building. He discharged his pastoral duties until 1824 when he became disqualified by age, He died of paralysis in 1829. Mr. Philips rendered valuable service to the state at the time of the "whiskey insurrection." Although always a prominent citizen he accepted no political honors. His remains were laid in the burying ground of the Peters Creek Church.

    Dr. James Estep's name was a household word inmy boyhood's home. I learned to reverence it with that of Adoniram Judson. James Estep was baptized into the fellowship of the Mt. Moriah Church in April, 1802. He pursued the study of medicine foreighteen months, when a sermon preached by the Rev. Morgan J. Rhees, at that time prothronotory of Somerset County, led him to reflection as to his true vocation. In a few days he was preaching. His life was

    [ 101 ]

    spent in Southwestern Pennsylvania, and as an instructive teacher, judicious counsellor, and helpful friend he was widely known and as widely loved. His was a gracious spirit, and in the controversies of the early part of the nineteenth century he rendered invaluable service to the Baptist cause by his equipoise and sagacious leadership.

    To explain the frequent reference in this part of our history to violent and bitter controversies I must introduce as in a parenthesis a man of different temper, though of no less fidelity to his convictions, -- William Brownfield, who became pastor of the Great Bethel Baptist Chuch, Uniontown, Pa., in 1812. Although he does not appear within the geographical boundary I have prescribed for myself, his attitude and conduct helped to produce effects felt very keenly not only here and at the time, but over a vast extent, and still tremendously potent. Though without college training, Brownfield was a diligent student, acquainted with Hebrew, Greek and other languages, well versed in church history, and a migbty debater. There had been much doctrinal strife with Alexander Campbell on account of his interpretations of the Scriptures. The climax came at a meeting of the Redstone Association in the old Redstone Church in 1826. There was a large crowd both inside and outside the building. Many were lending a voice to the discussion, but Brownfield and Campbell were the principal disputants. "Finally," says O. J. Sturgis, in his Historical Sketch of the Great Bethel Church, "Alexander Campbell picked up his hat and walking out of the chach announced that he was going to preach outside. He went down a little way, mounted a stump and began to preach. He soon had a great crowd around him. He proclaimed his views without interruption and soon after ceased his connection with

    [ 102 ]

    the Baptists. Dr. James Estep, a venerable father in the Redstone Association, writing his recollection of it in 1856, said, 'From the idea I had of Mr. Campbell, if he had been approached in kindness and Christian affection he would have been induced to modify if not to abandon that sentiment, but he was treated by some of the leading members of the Association in a most impulsive and forbidding manner. Hence the legend in almost every old Baptist family in western Pennsylvania: 'If Alexander Campbell had been treated kindly he never would have separated from the Baptists.' Dr. Estep here plainly refers to William Brownfield, with whom he himself has had many a tilt. But probably the best defense that can be made for Brother Brownfield at this day in answer to Dr. Estep's indictment is that he had no patience with what he regarded as heresy."

    Mr. Brownfield opposed the organization of the Home and Foreign Missionary Societies as unscriptural and unbaptistic. There were stormy scenes in the Association. This doughty defender of the faith that was in him died at the ripe age of eighty-six years.

    Another champion of Baptist principles was John Winter. He was bom in England in 1794, and settled in this city in 1822. Here he taught school and preached. He became pastor of the First Baptist Church at a most trying time of disruption and odium caused by the promulgation of erratic opinions by Sidney Rigdon, a former pastor, and who afterwards became an active leader and organize, of the Mormon movement. Dr. Winter's advocacy of pure Baptist doctrine, and his efficient direction of affairs were of great value in the crisis. He had several pastorate in western Pennsylvania and Ohio, and was everywhere a resolute upholder of Andrew Fuller's theology, which he maintained to he the best expression of Baptist truth.

    [ 103 ]

    At a much later date he again made his home in Pittsburgh. He supplied for a time the Penn Avenue Church, afterwards called the Shady Avenue Church, and was chosen the first editor of "The Baptist Witness," a religious weekly that lived a few years and was absorbed by "The National Baptist."

    Samuel Willians was an outstanding man in his day. He was born in Connellsville in 1802, and was ordained in Somerset Co. He becae pastor of the First Church, Pittsburgh, in 1827, when the membership numbered forty-two, and the situation was far from promising. He continued in this relation for twenty-eight years, during which six other churches were organized. He removed in 1856 to Akron, Ohio, where he remained eight years, and then went to Springfield. He returned to western Pennsylvania later. With voice and pen he took his share in the controversies of those fighting days.

    For some years there was a Baptist church edifice in Pittsburgh, erected as a memorial to Dr. William Shadrach. It is a pity there is not a permanent memorial to keep his memory green among us, for be was a man of the Spirit and of power. He was born in Wales in 1804 and came to this country when fifteen years of age. He received ordination in 1828, and became pastor of the Mt. Pleasant Church. He served with signal success Loyalbanna, Peters Creek, and Sandusky Street, Allegheny. From Sandusky Street, he went to Philadelphia. He was one of the founders of the University at Lewisburg. For three years he was Agent of the Pennsylvania State Convention, and later Corresponding Secretary of the American Baptist Publication Society. In preaching ability and in all the intellectual qualifications of the minister he was the peer of his most gifted contemporaries in our denomination, Cone, Ide, Stow, etc. In personality and character

    [ 104 ]

    he was equally distinguished. His public prayers were remarkable, His manner of absolute reverence was itself sufficient to impress and solemnize the hearer, and the petitions were models of simplicity and directness. It is written of Dr. Shadrach, "If fidelity to truth, earnest convictions, impassioned eloquence and active zeal through half a century entitle a clergyman to peculiar prominence among his brethren, such prominence must be awarded this veteran minister."

    If the scope permitted ygelf had been broader it would have been imperative to dwell on the names of Jesse Thomas and Benjamin H. Thomas who in succession served the Reidsburg and Clarion Churches for a period of seventy years, and who were among the most useful and influential ministers of our denomination in the state. They are buried together behind the pulpit of the Reidsburg Church.

    The second group I designate the Epigones or successors. A quarter of a centuy had seen the number of churches increased, and of course the number of pastors also. The Baptists had their place established.

    In December, 1856, David J. Yerkes, "the mountain orator," a preacher of e.ceptional homiletical and retorical talent became the pastor of the First Church, and remained four years when he went to Brooklyn, N. Y. He was succeeded by George D. Chase, and Mr. Chase by James S. Dickerson, who came from Wilmington, Delaware. His pastorate covered five fruitful years. He is remembered for his attractiveness as a preacher, and even more tenderly for his charming personality. He went from this city to Boston, Mass.

    The Sandusky Street Church, organized in 1835, was served, after Dr. Shadrach, by John E. Thomas, who baptized a large number; by N. G. Collins, during whose pastorate a new church edifice W2S erected, and by several others among them Isaac Sawyer who in after...

    [ 105 ]

    (pages 105-145 not transcribed)

    [ 146 ]

    ...Rev. J. W. Moody: -- I am a member of the oldest church in this association, which was fair, fat and forty when this church was organized, and instead of spending the time in my own personal reminiscences I propose to read a brief sketch of the Peters Creek Church beginning with its organization. This was written at the 125th anniversary of the Church when I was pastor of the Church.

    On the tenth day of November, 1773 (nearly 140

    [ 147 ]

    years ago, now Jan. 1913) the organization now known as the Peters Creek Baptist Church, at Library, Pa., was formed near the mouth of the Yough River. When constituted it had nine members, as follows: John Whitaker, minister; Thomas Applegate, Izun Barnet, Henry Lemmons, Peter Elrod, Christopher Mjller, Mary Whitaker, Margaret Jaret and Ailey Lemmons.

    From the place of its founding it was, after a time, moved to a point on Peters Creek, near what is now Gastonville. How long it remained at either of these places the present writer has no means of knowing. Late in the last, or early in the present century, the church was moved to what is now Library, Allegheny, Co., Pa.

    On the first of September, 1780, David Philips was received "into full communion by letter," but where from doth not appear. The same day he was elected, with two others, as a "messenger" to the association, and was also made a deacon.

    In November, 1780, he was "nominated to act as an elder in the church upon trial." On the 7th of April, 1781, he was "called to the ministry of the church at Peters Creek." He was "ordained May the 1st, of the same year," "at the request of the same church." The Rev. William Wood and the Rev. William Taylor assisted, Mr. Wood preaching the sermon from I Cor. 2; 4th and 5th verses. In April, 1802, he baptized James Estep. These isolated facts are gleaned from memoranda found by the writer among old papers, now in the possession of Brother Jasper Philips and Dr. W. T. Philips, who are his direct descendants, except the baptism referred to, which was found in a pamphlet published by Mr. Estep in 1854, at which time the church celebrated his fiftieth year in the ministry.

    Among matters of interest found in the old papers referred to is the fact that during the first ten years of

    [ 148 ]

    the history of the church there were a few very unruly members, who were dealt with with much love and patience, suspended from membership, and in some cases restored on confession of fault.

    Whiskey was in those days a commodity in which the pastor dealt quite extensively, the price being about fifty cents per gallon. On one consignment there was a lamentable wasteage of seven gallons when it was "drawed from the hogshead." In another "it fell short six and a half gallons." Thus it will be seen that even in those days the pastor did not always get his due. That word can be spelled either "due" Or "dew."

    Elder Philips was a man who had opinions, and was not afraid to express them. In 1828 the Court of Common Pleas of Washington County appointed a commission of three persons to interview the pastor and "find out whether you are non compos mentis." The finding of this commission is not recorded so far as the writer knows, but judging from some of his writings he seemed to be sane enough. At any rate he had sense enough to measure the whiskey he purchased and to discover that some of that which he supposed he had purchased was non est.

    The records of the church seem to have been imperfectly kept, many of them being entirely lost. The history written by Isaac King, and read 25 years ago, cannot be found. In fact, only in recent years does there seem to have been any kept of a tangible character. This is a lamentable fact and should warn the present history making generation that they ought not to live for themselves alone.

    The following pastors have served the church, so far as can be discerned, since the times of Elder David Philips:

    J. Estep, 1839 to 1856; D. Williams, 1859 to 1863; G. Seymour, 1864 to 1865; J. M. Collins, 1866 to 1867;

    [ 149 ]

    A. J. Collins, 1869 to 1872; H. Lewellyn, 1873; T. J. Bristow, 1866 to 1867; A. J. Collins, (second pastorate) September 1877 until his death in October, 1878; J. K. Cramer from February, 1879 to November, 1888; J. S. Hutson, 1889; E. R. Tilton, 1890; H. G. Bond, 1895; John W. Moody, the present incumbent, settled January 1, 1897.

    This fragmentary synopsis is not written with the idea that it is an exhaustive history of the church. The pastor has in mind the preparation of a more elaborate record, but the sources of information are so few and far between that he almost despairs of ever completing the task, so that it would be worthy to occupy a place in the archives of the denomination.

    November 10th, 1898, (at which time the one hundred and twenty-fifth anniversary of the church was observed, the day being very wet and unpleasant.)...

    [ 150 ]

    (pages 150-213 not transcribed)

    [ 214 ]


    Personal Exhibits.

    ISAAC YOHE. -- Minute books of the Old Redstone Baptist Association, dating back to 1776, and containing much of the Brownfield-Campbell controversies, which led to the separation of the Campbells and the Baptists, in 1826, and the organization of the Disciples, or Christian Church; also showing the anti-mission trend of the times, even inquiring, "To what length may a minister go in preaching to sinner?" His Exhibit also contained pictures of Thomas and Alexander Campbell, one of Joseph Smith, illustrating his connection with Sidney Rigdon in founding the Mormon church; a number of old church minute books, maps showing the location of anti-mission Baptist churches, etc.

    REV. J. F. MILLER. -- Photographs of Bentleysville and North Ten Mile Baptist church edifices, Program of the 125th Anniversary of the North Ten Mile church, held in 1898, the latter two being loaned by A. H. Bigler, of Bentleysville.

    MRS. A. H. MERCER. -- Photographs of prominent ministers of a generation ago.

    REV. A. B. BOWSER. -- Bow and arrows, and a "beheading knife," missioary trophies from Central Africa.

    MRS. BERLIN. -- Pictures of Morton school, Moulmein, Burma, and of Miss Whitehead, missionary from Pittsburgh.

    J. S. HUTSON, D. D. -- Photograph of William Codville, D. D., J. S. Wrightnour, D. D., Rev. C. F. Ralston and himself

    [ 215 ]

    REV. A. M. GREGG. -- A picture of the John Corbley family burying place in Whiteley cemetery, Greme County, Pa., showing the graves of the members of the Corbley family who were immsacred by Indians.

    F. J. RUBBECK. -- Files of the Baptist Expositor, charts, etc.

    REV. J. V. STRATTON. -- Pictures of Rev. David Chandler, missionary to China; A. P. Graves, D. D., a successful evangelist of forty years ago; Jacob Reese, a prominent layman; Mr. and Mrs. Williai Reese, two founders of the Sharpsburgh Church, and others.

    REV. H. C. GLEISS. -- Album of Rochester Seminary class of 1893, and a large number of photographs illustrating our missionary Work among the foreign speaking peoples of Pittsburgh and vicinity.

    JOHN A. BROWN. -- A copy of Benedict's History of the Baptist Denomination, dated 1848.

    MISS AUGUSTA STEWART. -- Pictures of the industrial classes of foreign children, in the Forty-sixth Street Church.

    REV. M. B. SLOAN. -- A large photograph of Rev. A. K. Bell, D. D., and photograph of Mr. Sloan, taken in his captain's uniform, during the Civil War.

    GEO. F. MCEWAN. -- Old Song books of 1841.

    Miss MINNIE EATON. -- Picture of Mrs. Leonard H. Eaton.

    MISS LILLIAN SAWYER. -- Picture of Italian girls class, etc.

    MRS. AMALIE PAULINEY. Class picture showing the beginning of foreign work in Rankin by Miss Lyde Jenkins.

    [ 216 ]

    REV. A. J. BONSALL. -- Pictures of Rev. John Winter, Rev. David Williams, et. al., and file of the Baptist Witness.

    MRS. J. L. JONES. -- File of Sunday-school papers from the First church school, 1860, bound by Anna R. Jack.

    PROF. EMIL HANKE. -- Mounted pictures of the buildings of the Western Pa. Classical and Scientific Institute, Mt. Pleasant, Pa. and of Dr. Bell, the first president.

    J. L. MCCASKEY, -- A miniature "Microcosm", illustrating "Industrial Conditions."

    The above list does not contain many of the smaller articles which were of considerable interest to folks in the locality from which they came, but were not of general interest or importance.

    Many of the articles have been donated for the permanent Exhibit which will be arranged in the near future and will be carefully preserved in a fire-proof room. It is hoped that many other articles of historic value will be added to this collection.

    The First Baptist
    Church of Pittsburgh

    (Pittsburgh: Baptist Church, 1925)

  • Title-page
  • Sidney Rigdon
  • Samuel Williams

  • Transcriber's Comments

  • THE





    [ 1 ]




    The early historical data are taken very largely from the History of The First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh, read at the closing services of the Fourth Avenue Meeting House, March 6, 1910, and from the Centennial address, April 6, 1912, both by the late Rev. Joel V. Stratton; and from the Seventy-Fifty Anniversary of the Fourth Avenue Church, 1887, by Rev. Lemuel C. Barnes, D.D.; also to a slight extent from several Histories of Pittsburgh, some of which were by no means biased in favor of Baptists. There are no contemporary records of the early years, and much of the data was from memories of quite old people in the year 1887.


    [ 2 ]



    [ 3 ]

    PITTSBURGH  IN  1817
    Five years after the First Baptist Church was organized. This view is from the Ohio River
    looking toward the Point with the Allegheny River on the left and the Monongahela on
    the right. The columns of smoke are probably "Mr. Page's glass-house" at the foot of
    Grant Street.  (By the courtesy of the Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania.)


    THE first Baptist Church in Pittsburgh was organized in 1812, probably in the month of April. At that time the town, with less than five thousand inhabitants, and about eight hundred houses, lay in the level tract between Wood Street and the Point, with dwellings and farms higher up along the banks of the Allegheny and Monongahela rivers. Some of the landscape features were Quarry, Grant's and Biyd's Hills, with woods and fields, also four ponds where wild ducks abounded. The streets were dark at night and only a few were paved. Stage-coaches and freight wagons furnished transportation to Philadelphia and Baltimore. The first steamboat made its first trip to New Orleans early in 1811.

    The First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh began with twelve members,

    4                               THE  FIRST  BAPTIST  CHURCH  OF  PITTSBURGH                               

    including the first pastor, Edmon Jones, who came from England and was aicensed preacher, and also a glass worker, supporting himself like the apostle Paul by his trade; Richard James, from England, who was also a charter member in 1822; a family named Ensell, probably Edward Ensell, Sr., and Edward Ensell, Jr., glass-blowers living in "Birmingham," i.e., on the south side of the Monongahela River, and probably also the "Encell" of "Trevor & Encell, Glass Warehouse, Water between Market & Wood, as given in the Pittsburgh Directory of 1815; a family named Bruner, or Brenner, from England; William H. Hart and wife from Rhode Island (he was one of the Trustees in 1822, and was for a long time deacon of the church, and toll collector of the Smithfield Street bridge across the Monongahela River); a Mr. Green and his wife from one of the New England States. The pastor and the Ensells, and probably one or more of the other members, worked in "Mr. (Benjamin) Page's flint glass factory," the first of its kind in America. Edward Ensell, Sr., is supposed to have brought the knowledge of the flint glass business from England. In 1887 there were two daughters of Edward Ensell living. The First Church was organized by the ministerial delegates from the Redstone Baptist Association, David Phillips, Henry Spears and James Fry.

    The list of pastors for the first one hundred years, as carved on the vestibule wall of the present church building, is shown in the illustration on the next page.
    These names are a veritable roll of men of apostolic type. The one exception is Sidney Rigdon, who in a very brief pastorate almost wrecked the church, and was excluded from its membership and deposed from the Baptist ministry. He afterwards became one of the founders of Mormonism, and he is understood to have stolen Solomon Spaulding's manuscript which became the "Book of Mormon."

                                                  HISTORICAL                                                5

    The First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh from 1812 to 1820 met from house to house. The earliest public places of meeting were a "hall-shop" (i.e., a hall over a shop) on old Fifth Avenue, and a similar room on Second Avenue, said to have been a school-room over a harness shop. In 1819, during Mr. Newcomb's pastorate, the church conducted a bible school. The first meeting house owned by the church was at the corner of Third Avenue and Grant Street, on a leased lot. The building was a one-story frame about thirty by forty feet. This was built in 1820 during the ministry of John Davis, who came from England and was of repute as an "evangelist," and who baptized sixty-two persons, beinging the membership to one hundred six. While this meeting house was building the church met in the home of deacon John P. Skelton on the south side of the Monongahela.

    On October 30, 1822, the church was chartered by the Supreme Court of the State of Pennsylvania as "The First Baptist Church and Congregation of the City of Pittsburgh."


    Early map showing location of First Baptist Church on NE corner of 3rd and Grant streets


    6                               THE  FIRST  BAPTIST  CHURCH  OF  PITTSBURGH                               

    The charter members were as follows:

    Sidney Rigdon
    James Morford
    Benjamin Pyatt
    William H. Hart
    Zebeon Packard
    John Robinson
    John P. Skelton
    A. Sinclair
    John Morford
    Thomas Parel
    Francis Johnson
    William Trimble
    John White
    Robert Douglas
    John Curry
    Frederick Wendt
    M. Evans
    Mark Stackhouse
    Robert Warnock
    Alfred Lloyd
    Washington McErwen
    James J. Carpenter
    Caleb Lee
    Eliot S. Neal
    Thomas C. Lee
    Robert Shepard
    Silas Wickes
    Richard James
    John Hurrell
    John Alexander
    Jesse Dewees

    The first trustees were: James Morford, Zebeon Packard, Benjamin Pyatt, John Robinson, William H. Hart, John P. Skelton, William Sarvey.

    The membership of the church at this time was approximately one hundred. Washington McEwen, who was baptized in the Allegheny River by pastor John Davis in the year 1819, and who had been deacon, choir leader and bible school superintendent, was present in 1887 at the seventy-fifth anniversary of the church. Zebeon Packard was the first clerk of the Pittsburgh Baptist Association when it was organized in 1839; his widow, who was a member in 1822, was living in the year 1887. Descendants of charter members are to-day to be found in Pittsburgh and vicinity, most of whom are members of the First Church or of other Baptist churches.

    During the next pastorate, short and diastrous, of Rigdon, the rental

                                                  HISTORICAL                                                7

    From 1812 to 1858 the Monongahela "from the bridge to the glass house" was the church's place of baptism Beginning at the left, the buildings are the home of William Wilkins, the
    old woolen mill (where the Monongahela House now stands), Irwin's tavern, the Anderson mansion, the Bakewell and Page glass-house, where the first pastor and others of the early members of the church worked.

    on the lot was unpaid and the building was lost to the church. When Samuel Williams began his long pastorate in 1827 the membership was only forty-two. In a little over a year he succeeded in buying the lot and building with it for one thousand dollars, of which one-half was borrowed "from the bank." In 1833 this little frame building was replaced on the same site by a two-story brick structure costing four thousand dollars. As long ago as 1841, anti-slavery meetings were held in this building which was destroyed in "The Great Fire" of 1845, but in less than two years thereafter, under the indomitable leadership of Samuel Williams, a larger brick building of two stories was completed at a cost of eight thousand dollars. From the organization of the church in 1812 until 1858, a period of forty-six years, the Monongahela River had been the place of baptism. Samuel Williams, in his letter of reminiscences, written in 1886, thirty years after the close of his long pastorate, says: "Between the glass factory and the bridge was our Jordan. I think in nearly every rod from one to the other I have buried candidates

    8                               THE  FIRST  BAPTIST  CHURCH  OF  PITTSBURGH                               

    PITTSBURGH  IN  1849
    From a lithograph, made four years after the great fire when the second meeting house of the First Baptist Church was burned, and two years after a third house was built at the corner of Grant and Third. The court house (burned in 1882), with dome and pillars, was at Grant and Fifth. The First Church building cannot be clearly distibguished, but probably is a small two-story building to the right of a larger building just below the right hand part of the court house.


                                                  HISTORICAL                                                9

    in the likeness of My Saviour's burial and resurrection." In 1858 a baptistry was installed in the building. There are still with us a few persons who were baptized in this baptistry.... *

    (remainder of text not transcribed)

    * 1886 Samuel Williams letter preserved in the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh:

    188 Tompkins Av Brooklyn NY Aug 16th [18]86

    Dear Br[others]

    You almost ask for my memoir. On Page 617 of Benedict's H[ostory] there is a very brief account of the origin of the lst [Baptist Church], but the month is not mentioned. In his older history or in Allen's Register the exact date perhaps might be found. The loss of the old church book was careless and reckless on the part of the Treasurer.

    As I stated before Edward Jones was their first Pastor who came with several members from Eng who were glass blowers, working in the first flint factory built on the spot occupied now by [the railroad] Depot at the foot of the St. between which and the Bridge was our Jordan. I think on nearly every rod from one to the other, I have buried candidates in the likeness of my Saviour's burial and resurrection. I think the [church] was formed in the month of April. Mr. Jones served them two years, Mr. Newcombe from New Eng[land] about the same time Samuel Davis (not John) was with them 4 or 5 years and many were added to the [church], but he drank liquor and sunk out of sight and died not long afterwards.

    Several of the ministers of the Redstone Association were present at the constitution. The Pastor, Richard James, a family of Enseleys, and one named Bruner were from Birmingham Eng. Some of these were connected with a window glass factory on the other side of the River and they called the little village after the town in Eng[land] from which they came. Some H. Hart was from Rhode Island, and a Mr. Green from some other part of Eng[land]. These are the constituent members. Along in [eighteen] twenty one, two, and three Sidney Riqdon who was a member at Peters Creek; occasionally preached for them, they called him, he embraced Campbelism first, then his common stock system as he called [it], and getting hold of a "Manuscript Novel" written by Spalding, he garbled it and interspersed passages of scripture so as to make it appear like a revelation favoring his communism.

    Shortly before this Robert Owen, Fanny Wright, and two or three French Infidels had been lecturing through this country, and no doubt, he indulged the conceit that he could form a community under the guise of Christianity and enrich himself and his fellow elders at the same time. When I came on the [scene] I wrote an Exposure of his rascalities, but I do not know where you could see a copy, except in the [hand?] of Mr. Patterson, one of the editors of the Pres[byterian] paper.

    A Mr Greatrake supplied the church about five or six months, then Rev. Joshua Bradley from Albany became Pastor, remaining only one year, baptised a few and gathered back a few who had gone with Rigdon or an associate [[Scott]] of the troubles at that time.

    Then I was called, but did not accept until two or three months. I was 25 and in one year married one of the members, a young widow of my age, who died at 40 and in another year, having one small daughter, married a Methodist lady and gave her the New Testament to study and in about another year baptized her in the river at her request presented to the [church] without my knowledge until the meeting, who is still living with our two children and two grandchildren, through abounding mercy a happy family.

    When studying at an Academy at Zanesville, [Ohio] I was converted under the preaching of Geo. C. Sedwick who had been a student of Dr. Staughton's of Phila[delphia] and soon after began to speak in public. He put Gill's Divinity and Mosheim's [Church History] in my hands, directing my studies for two years. By too close application, I came near death with typhoid fever. When partially recovered our Dr deacon sent me off to Bedford Springs, PA. I soon began to improve and a [Presbyterian] Church there had lately lost their Pastor and urged me to preach for them, where I received the first little salary for 18 months. Passing through Pittsburgh I preached for them on Wednesday evening, and in a few weeks received their call.

    Very shortly after I accepted, the Presbyterian Theo[logical] Sem[inary] was organized, and I asked the Professors and Trustees if they would not allow me to enjoy the privileges of the Sem[onary]. They gave me a cordial invitation to do so. The first class numbered about one dozen, only to or three are not living, one died in India. Dr. [Sawyer] the Secretary] of their For[eign] Board in NY was one of them. I kept along with the class and filled my Pulpit.

    The old church book would show that from about three months after I began to preach there was a baptism every ordinance day for eight years, never more than eight and, often not more than one at a time. The most satisfactory part of the church's history.

    We had several quite large additions after evangelists came about, but there was always trouble of some sort would arise. I think 36 was the largest number I baptised at one time. The Lot was originally taken on ground rent and when Rigdon came to them, the rent was not paid and it fell back in to the hands of the proprietor with the one storyed house the church had built. After I had been there about fifteen months I bought the property for $1000 in cash. We raised the hall and borrowed the other half for one year. We used that house until 1833 when we built a plain good brick for $4000. This was burned in the great fire 1845 Then I raised money, paying $1100 of my own, to build that house for $8000. We had on hand some insurance money from the old house. The brick only cost $30 per 1000 lumber $6 but several of our brethren thought the house was not as good as it ought to be. They were becoming wealthy and wanted a finer house. I was well pleased with the one the Lord had given us, and on this account they were not pleased with me. The[y] made all the trouble they could, but had I only understood their wishes better I would have left them at first. No one could be better pleased than I to see them spend thousands to build a better house of worship that I had built for them.

    At length I received a pressing call from Akron, [Ohio], where I remained eight years, but sickness moved us to Springfield, [Ohio] where we were eight years. Having some little property at, or near Pittsburg, we concluded to end our days in a pleasant country home. But our children leaving us and settling in New York, we concluded to follow them, so we are here. I still preach occasionally in City and country pulpits, On the 5th inst the children celebrated my 84 birthday on Glen island, a most delightful resort. In regard to my literary work I may say that I have been forced to write almost everything I have written by stress of circumstances. First Campbelism had to be combatted next Mormonism exposed. Then, simultaneously, the paidobaptist ministers in West Pa and [Ohio] attacked our view of baptism. Millerism came next. Slavery was a huge evil to be fought as a chief work of the devil which Christ was manifested to destroy.

    I started the 'Christian Witness" on Jan 16th 1836, which did good service. A number of tracts, and a great many articles for newspapers, on temperance and many other matters, but I have but a few copies of only a few of the things I have written. I wish you could have seen my review of Moxom's great discourse published in the Standard of Chicago.

    We have now the strongest hold of Satan to contend with and christians more reluctant to attack it than to combat any other sin. on election day they seem to think they have no moral responsibility to be on the Lord's side.

    I would be glad to give you more full and satisfactory answers to some of [y]our questions, but I have done the best I could.

    I am glad to see that the church you serve is doing her share in the great work of giving the gospel to the world. May the lord prosper and bless your labors there.

    S. Williams

    History of Churches of
    Pittsburgh Baptist Assoc.

    by William R. Pankey
    (Phiiladephia: Judson Press, 1939)

  • Forward
  • Baptist Beginnings
  • Peters Creek Baptist Church
  • Pittsburgh 1st Baptist Church
  • Peters Creek

  • Entire contents copyright © 1939, William R. Pankey
    (only limited, "fair use" excerpts are reproduced here)

    [ vii ]


    At the annual meeting of the Pittsburgh Baptist Association, held at the Apollo Church, June 4, 1873, the following resolution was adopted:

    "RESOLVED, that the Rev. Dr. John Winter be requested to write the history of the Baptists of western Pennsylvania, and to have the same published in the 'National Baptist,' or in some other permanent form."

    No trace of such a publication has been found, and we therefore conclude that this noble resolution went the way of the majority of resolutions.

    The most outstanding layman who was zealous in collecting and preserving historical data was the late Francis J. Rebbeck. He served for thirty-two years as Cleark and Assistant Clerk of the Pittsburgh Association. Two historical sketches of the churches were published by him in the Association Annuals of 1889 and 1899.

    A volume entitled, Centenary of Organized Bpatist Work in and about Pittsburgh, was published by the Pittsburgh Association in 1913. This, however, is not a historical narrative, but merely a compilation

    [ viii ]

    of the addresses delivered at the centennial meetings of the First Baptist Church, Pittsburgh, January 30, 31, 1913.

    At the annual meeting of the Pittsburgh Association, June 3, 4, 1837, a resolution was adopted authorizing the Reverend William R. Pankey and Mr. Lewis C. Walkinshaw to write and publish a complete history of the churches of the Association, the task to be completed prior to the centennial celebration in June of 1939.

    By mutual consent it was agreed that the first section of the book should deal with the general movement and settlement of Baptists in western Pennsylvania, and the second with the histories of the individual Baptist churches in the Pittsburgh Association. Mr. Walkinshaw accepted the responsibility for the first part, while I was given the responsibility for writing the second section.

    In the meantime, the sudden and untimely death of Mr. Walkinshaw has made it impossible for his unfinished manuscript to be included in this volume. This is a decided loss. However, it is hoped that the seventy-two historical sketches of the churches contained herein, together with the brief introductory chapter, may be found useful and interesting to all lovers of Baptist history. April 24, 1939   W. R. P.

    [ ix ]

    (pages ix-xii not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ xiii ]


    Prior to 1692, the vast territory extending westward from the Allegheny Mountains was inhabited by the native Indians only. In that year the first trader, Arnold Viele, made a journey across the headwaters of the Allegheny River from the Hudson and upper Delaware, and traveled down the Allegheny and Ohio to the Shawnee Indian country. Upon his return he brought a group of Shawnee Indians, who established themselves in a village on the upper Delaware. About the year 1725, they became dissatisfied with the measurement of the "walking purchase" of the Penns and migrated to the Forks of the Ohio, where they established several towns.

    Traders from the East soon followed the Indians across the mountains. In quick succession these trails became highways for the pioneering settlers, and the marching military forces that followed. As the military establishments became stronger, affording more protection to these early settlers, the religious foundations were gradually laid. No substantial religious establishments were attempted until 1768, when the Penns made their purchase of

    [ xiv ]

    the area west of Laurel Hill and south of the purchase line between Cherry Tree, and Kittanning. Prior to that date, western Pennsylvania was the scene of bloody combats between the Indians, the English and the French soldiers.

    In the parlance of historical genealogy, the Pittsburgh Baptist Association is the great-great-grand-daughter of the Philadelphia Baptist Association. The Baptist Associations formed in the were in the following order: Philadelphia (Pennsylvania), 1707; Charlston (South Carolina), 1751; Sandy Creek (North Carolina), 1758; Kehukee,

    [ xv ]

    (North Carolina), 1765; Ketoctin (Virginia), 1766; Warren (Connecticut), 1767; Stonington, (Connecticut), 1772; Redstone (Pennsylvania), 1776; Shaftsbury (New York, Massachusetts, Vermont), 1781; New York, 1791; Baltimore, 1792. The Charleston Association became the progenitor of the Associations to the southward, except Ketoctin. The Ketoctin, Warren and New York Associations were forned from the Philadelphia Baptist Association. The Minutes of the Philadelphia Association for 1764 have the following entry:

    "Concluded to receive the Church at Ketoctin, and the church of Opekon, in Virginia, into flic fellowship with this Association."

    The Ketoctin Baptist Association was formed in 1766, pursuant to the following action taken by the Philadelphia Baptist Association

    "Agreed that the Churches in Virginia have our leave to form themselves into an Association, provided

    [ xvi ]

    they go on the same plan, and hold union with us."

    In addition to the Ketoctin Church, Mill Creek Church, Smith's Creek Church and Broad Run Church became constituent members of the Ketoctin Association. By the year 1809, this Association reported thirty-six churches and two thousand members.

    About the year 1768 there came into the Redstone country, from New Jersey, the Reverend Henry Crosley (Crosbye) and the Reverend Isaac Sutton. With the assistance of others, these New Jersey preachers organized, in 1770, the Great Bethel Baptist Church, at Beesontown, now Uniontown. This is the oldest church west of the Allegheny Mountains.

    The main stream of Baptist life in western Pennsylvania flowed down the Monongahela valley from Virginia. In subsequent years other Baptist streams flowed from the mountaintop at old Beulah, near Ebensburg, and still others from western New York. All of these streams had their source at Philadelphia.

    A few years prior to 1770, there began a general movement of pioneer Virginians into the Redstone country. Numbered among these pioneers was the Reverend John Corbly. His missionary activities resulted in the organization of the Goshen, the North

    [ xvii ]

    Ten Mile and the Peters Creek Baptist Churches, in 1773. The Turkey Foot Baptist Church was organized in 1775, and many others followed in quick succession.

    The Redstone Baptist Association was organized October 7, 1776, with the following six cgurches as constitutent members: Great Bethel, Goshen, North Ten Mile, Peters Creek, Pine Run and Turkey Foot.

    At the annual meeting of the Redstone Baptist Association, August 31, 1832, Forks of the Yough Church (Salem), Turkey Foot Church (Confluence), and Loyalhanna Church (Saltsburg), were dismissed to form the Monongahela Baptist Association, with the National Turnpike as the boundary line, but with the privilege of any church on either side of that line to change its Association affiliation whenever it was deemed desirable.

    The Pittsburgh Baptist Association was organized in 1839, by a group of churches withdrawing from

    [ xviii ]

    the Monongahela Baptist Association for that specific purpose. Included among the charter churches constituting the Pittsburgh Association were, Great Bethel, Peters Creek, and all the then existing churches in the city of Pittsburgh. Today there are seventy-four churches in the Pittsburgh Association, with a total membership of approximately twenty thousand.

    [ 1 ]


    of the


    [ 2 ]


    [ 3 ]


    ORGANIZED 1773

    This historic church is the oldest congregation in the Pittsburgh Baptist Association. The record shows that in 1775 the members met at five different places to hold communion: Laural Hill, Corse, the church at the forks of the Youghiogheny River, Muddy Creek, and Ten Mile. The first church edifice was probably at the forks of the Yiughiogheny River, now McKeesport. A later record indicates that services were conducted in a log house on the farm of Robert Estep -- the present site of Venetia.

    In 1780, David Phillips came from Chester county, where he had been a member of the Grear Valley Baptist Church. He purchased the farm where the Peter's Creek Church is now located, calling it "Nonevah." The organization was at first called "the church upon Peters creek." According to records in the Washington County Court House, "the trustees of Peters Creek Baptist church purchased a building site of John Cox, the transfer being made September 10, 1788." This Cox farm was near the present town of Gastonville.

    [ 4 ]

    The records of Washington Ciunty assert that "Rev. David Phillips was called to preach in April 1781, and was ordained the following May, and from that date he preached at Elizabethtown, Gastonville, and Budd's Ferry on the Youghiogheny River, until 1793."

    Shortly after 1794 the Gastonville and Elizabethtown churches were united in the calling of a pastor, but there is no record of what became of the "Church on the Youghiogheny."

    In 1797, a part of the lot, now the site of the Peters Creek church, was purchased. The first

    [ 5 ]

    edifice was a log chapel, which was replaced in 1832 by a brick edifice, at a cost of twelve hundred and fifty dollars. The theological controversy agitated by Alexander Campbell, following 1825, did much to weaken and divide the congregation.

    The centennial anniversary of the church was observed November 10, 1873. The third church edifice was erected in 1884, and has been used continuously by the congregation -- until the corner-stone of the present new edifice was laid, in 1938.

    The following members of the church have entered the Christian ministry: Charles Rigdon, John Rigdon, James Estep, Henry Wade, Joshua Phillips, J. W. Higbee, Sidney Rigdon, Frank Cramer, Frank King, John Erbe, John Lauderbaugh, Kimber Boyer, and Philip B. Boyer. In 1866 Miss Zillah Bunn was baptized in this church, later serving for twenty-five years as a missionary in India.

    The first Woman's Missionary Society was organized in the church August 11, 1878; it has had a continuous existence to date. Two of the early Sunday school superintendents were William McNary and Isaac King. Among the early deacons were Joseph Phillips, Joseph Higbee, Charles Dailey, Ephriam Estep, Isaac King, William Benson, John King, Joseph Phillips, Jr., John Maits, John Mairs, Jr., Samuel Heath, Peter Boyer, Samuel Boyer, Edward Riggs, and Isaac Phillips.

    The Peter's Creek church now seems to be on the

    [ 6 ]

    verge of another membership boom, due to the increasing number of families moving into the community. The present membership is 155. The following ministers have served the church: Rev. John Whitaker (1775-1780), Rev. David Phillips (1780-1824), Rev. Charles Wheeler (1824), Rev. John Winter (1825), Rev. Joshua Bradley (1826-1827), Rev. Alexander Campbell (1827-1828), Rev. William Shadrach (1829-1835), Rev. William Penny (1836-1837), Rev. Benoni Allen (1837-1838), Rev. James Estep (1838-1857)...

    (remainder of text through page 9 not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 10 ]


    ORGANIZED 1812

    The First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh was organized in 1812 with twelve constituent members. A ministerial delegation from the Redstone Baptist Associationm consisting of David Phillips, Henry Spears and James Fry, assisted in its organization

    For the first eight years of its existence the First Church met "from house to house." A Sundat school was started in 1819. The first meeting-house was a wooden chapel, erected in 1820, and located

    [ 11 ]

    on the corner of Third Avenue and Grant Street. Services were conducted in the home of Deacon John P. Skelton, on the south side of the Moningahela, while the edifice was in process of construction.

    The First Church was chartered in 1822, with the following charter members: Sidney Rigdon, James Morford, Benjamin Pyatt, William H. Hart, Zebeon Packard, John Robinson, John P. Skelton, A. Sinclair, John Morford, Thomas Parel, Francis Johnson, William Trimble, John White, Robert Douglas, John Curry, M. Evans, Mark Stackhouse, Robert Warnock, Alfred Lloyd, Washington McEwen [sic - McErwen?], James J. Carpenter, Caleb Lee, Eliot S. Neal, Thomas C. Lee, Robert Shepard, Silas Wickes, Richard James, John Hurrell, John Alexander, Jesse Dewees and Frederick Wendt.

    In 1833 the original wooden chapel was replaced by a two-story brick edifice costing four thousand dollars. This building was destroyed by fire in 1845. The third edifice was erected on the same site in 1846, at a cost of eight thousand dollars.

    From 1812 to 1858 the Monongahela River was the place of baptism. In his letter of reminiscences, written in 1886, the Rev. Samuel Williams says:

    "Between the glass factory and the bridge was our Jordan. I think in nearly every rod from one to the other I have buried candidates in the likeness of my Saviour's burial and resurrection.

    [ 12 ]

    The first baptistry was installed in the church in 1858.

    In 1865 the church building and lot were sold for ten thousand dollars. A new lot was purchased on the corner of Fourth Avenue and Grant Street, on which a cliapel was erected (in 1867), at a cost of forty thousand dollars. In 1876 the main church edifice, fronting on Ross Street, was dedicated.

    On March 3, 1873, the Fourth Avenue Baptist Church was constituted by the merger of the First and the Union Baptist Church. The spiritual and numerical strength of the congregation increased rapidly. Among some of the outstanding features of the life of the Fourth Avenue Church were an industrial school; outdoor meetings on the street corners; a city missionary and visiting nurse; a fresh air vacation caiiip for children; a school of housekeeping; the toy mission, begun in 1894; a Chinese Bible school; a Vacation Bible school, and the department for the deaf.

    On September 25, 1909, the Fourth Avenue Baptist Church became by charter the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh. During the same year the church property was sold to the Commissioners of Allegheny County, for five hundred and sixty thansand dollars. farewell services were held in the church March 6, 1910. A temporary meeting-plaee was rented on Neville Street until the new edifice was constructed at the corner of Bellefield Avenue

    [ 13 ]

    and Bayard Street. The new Gothic edifice was dedicated April 28, 1912, one hundred vears after the organization of the church.

    On April 1, 1929, the Oakland Baptist Church merged ivith the First, and its pastor, the Rev. Lester W. Bumpus, became the associate pastor of the enlarged First. The Oakland church had been organized in 1890. The present membership is 1,136.

    The following ministers have served the church:  Rev. Edmon Jones (1812-1814), Rev. Obadiah Newcomb (1818-1820), Rev. John Davis (1820-1822), Rev. Sidney Rigdon (1822-1823) Rev. John Winter (1823-1824), Rev. Lawrence Greatrake (1824-1825), Rev. Joshua Bradley (1826-1827), Rev. Samuel Williams (1827-1856), Rev. David J. Yerkes (1856-1860), Rev. George S. Chaise (1861-1864), Rev. James S. Dickerson (1865-1870), Rev. Adoniram J. Rowland (1870-1872), Rev. Robert W. Pearson (1873-1879), Rev. John H. Hartman (1879-1881), Rev. Lemuel Call Barnes (1882-1887), Rev. Howard B. Grose, (1888-1890), Rev. Henry C. Applegarth (1890-1893), Rev. Lemuel Call Barnes (1893-1902), Rev. Warren G. Partridge (1903- 1911), Rev. Frederic Tower Galpin (1912-1921), Rev. Carl Wallace Petty (1922-1932), Rev. Bernard C. Clausen (1933-  ).

    The following ministers have been associate pastors: Rev. IV. W. West, Rev. David Boswell, Rev. Theodore Miller and Rev. Lester W. Bumpus.

    [ 14 ]


    ORGANIZED 1814

    As an independent organization, the First Baptist Church of Washington was constituted October 14, 1814, with eleven charter members. It had operated as a mission for three years prior to its organization. In 1811, the State Legislature confirmed the title of the church to its lot on Wheeling Street -- then known as Belle Street. The first church edifice was erected on this lot in 1819. The second, located on East Wheeling Street, was dedicated, April 23, 1893. The present building located at the corner of College and West Wheeling Streets, was dedicated June 14, 1931.

    From 1815 to 1834 [sic], the church was a member of the Redstone [sic - and Washington?] Baptist Association. From 1835 to 1857, it was affiliated with the Monongahela Baptist Association. Since 1858 it has been a member of the Pittsburgh Association.

    In 1902 the First Baptist Church dismissed fifty-six members by letter to form the Broad Street Baptist Church, Washington. Again, in 1903, twenty-three more members were dismissed to form the Allison Avenue Baptist Church, Washington. In

    [ 15 ]

    1904 a missionary chapel was dedicated at Dea Caminos, Cuba, as a memorial to Rev. Stephen Drummond. Later in the same year a second chapel was built at Jiguani, Cuba.

    The following ministers have served the church: Rev. Charles Wheeler (1814-1838), Rev. B. Davis (1839), Rev. R. Billings (1841-1842), Rev. C. T. Johnson (1842-1843), Rev. J. B. W. Tisdale (1843-1846), Rev. H. Halping (1846), Rev. Thomas Swaim [sic - Swain?] (1846-1850), Rev. George W. Young (1850-1854), Rev. Malachi Taylor (1855-1858), Rev. John Boyd (1858-1859), Rev. H. Adams, Rev. R. Telford (1866-1868), Rev. J. A. Snodgrasss (1871-1874), Rev. Malnor C. Blaine (1875-1878), Rev. I. C. Tuttle (1879-1882), Rev. John Brooks (1884), Rev. Stephen Drummond (1884-1888), Rev. Alexander McArthur (1888-1890), Rev. W. S. Wedemeyer (1890-1891), Rev. Stephen Drummond (1892-1902), Rev. Charles W. Fletcher (1902 1912), Rev. M. A. Graybiel (1912-1916), Rev. F. B. Taber (1917-1930), Rev. William M. Kennedy (1931-  ). The present membership is 796.

    [ 16 ]

    (pages 16-23 not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 24 ]


    ORGANIZED 1834

    The Chatham Street Welsh Baptist Church, Pittsburgh, was organized in 1834. The first structure was a wooden chapel, erected in 1839. The present brick and stone building was erected in 1881. The membership is now small.

    The property of the church has been acquired within recent years by the First Pittsburgh Church, and is to be held perpetually for religious use. The First Church likewise sustains the Chatham Street Welsh Baptist Church financially.

    The following have been the ministers: Rev. William Owens (1834-1874), Rev. Rhoslyn Davies (1874-1894), Rev. R. C. Morgan (1895-1915). The, present pastor is Rev. Griff Thomas.

    [ 25 ]


    ORGANIZED 1835

    The Sandusky Street Baptist Church, Pittsburgh, originated in a series of cottage prayer-meetings. The organization took place March 7, 1835, in the edifice of the Methodist Protestant Church, Union

    [ 26 ]

    Avenue, and with fifteen constituent members who had been dismissed by letter from the First Baptist Church. The original corporate name of the organization was "The First Baptist Church of Allegheny," and it wts locited on Robinson Street. The first edifice was a wooden chapel, erected in 1835. John Wright was the first deacon, the first clerk, the first treasurer, the first chorister and the first Sunday school superintendent!

    The second church edifice was, erected in 1844, and was located on Sandusky Street. By 1865 all building debts had been paid. In 1857 the church withdrew from the Monongahela Baptist Association and became a member of the Pittsburgh Association. In 1867 the congregation helped orgnize the Nixon Street Baptist Church. In 1871, another mission Sunday school was organized on Howard Street. The third and present church edifice, was dedicated, November 19, 1893. In 1907 the charter name of the church was changed to "The Sandusky Street Baptist Church."

    Ministers who have gone out from the church include, Rev. J. Smith Gillespie, Rev. B. F. Woodburn, Rev. M. B. Sloan, Rev. J. A. Snodgrass, Rev. Aaron Wilson, Rev. T. H. Chapman and Rev. Henry Gellart. Others who have gone into Christian service include, Miss Zillah A. Bunn and Miss Agnes Whitehead.

    The following ministers have served the church:

    [ 27 ]

    Rev. William Shadrach (1835-1838), Rev. John E. Thomas (1838-1842), Rev. N. G. Collins (1843-1845), Rev. H. Silliman (1845-1846), Rev. Joseph Walker (1847-1849), Rev. Joseph B. Breed (1849-1850), Rev. J. R. Downer (l850-1853), Rev. T. R. Taylor (1853-1857), Rev. Isaac Sawyer (1858-1859), Rev. A. K. Bell (1859-1870), Rev. B. F. Woodburn (1870-1905), Rev. A. J. Bonsall (1906-1925), Rev. Joseph R. Allen (1925-1930), Rev. Charles S. Dayton (1930-1937), Rev. Edwin L. Kautz (1937-  ). The present membership is 407.

    The assistant pastors include Rev. Joseph N. Williams (1900-1901), Rev. William W. Barker (1902-1903), Rev. A. J. Bonsall (1904-1906), Rev. Clarles E. Stanton (1921-1925).

    [ 28 ]

    (remainder of text not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    175th Anniversary
    Peters Cr. Baptist Church

    by J. G. Lauderbaugh
    (Peters Creek Baptist Church, Library, PA, 1948)

  • Part 1: Historical Background
  • Part 2: (not transcribed)
  • Ch. 3: Pastors, Their Work
            Anti Mission Controversy
            Campbellite Controversy
            Mormonism Controversy

  • Entire contents copyright © 1948, Peters Creek Baptist Church
    (only limited, "fair use" excerpts are reproduced here)

    [ 10 ]

    PART I.

    *   *   *   *

    A Baptist Church which, a few years after its organization, was known as the Baptist Churcch on Peters Creek, was organized by some of the first pioneers who settled in the valley of Peters Creek and the adjacent territory of the Monongahela valley. It is one of more than half a score of Baptist churches organized about the same time by these pioneers within a radius of approximately thirty-five miles of Fort Burd it the present site of Brownsville. This bit of Colonial church history cannot be fully understood without noting the background of these pioneers. That background is linked up not only with the character and religious affiliations of these early settlers but also with certain matters of history east of the mountains, especially in Virginia from which the greatest number of these settlers came.

    Previous to that event in American history which is known as the French and Indian War the people living east of the Allegheny Mountains had comparatively little knowledge of that vast expanse of territory west of the mountains in the valley of the Ohio River and its tributaries. Some intrepid explorers had penetrated deep into that wilderness but any reports they made received but little publicity owing to the lack of facilities for publicising such reports. For a quarter of a century hardy traders had been crossing the mountains with their trade goods on packhorses to barter with the Indians but they seem to have said little about the country. However, certain events leading up to and during the French and Indian War were destined to bring a comparatively small section of that territory into general knowledge, a section nonv comprising for the most part five counties in the southwest corner of Pennsylvania: Fayette, Westmoreland, Allegheny, Washington and Greene Counties.

    When that little hand of forty Virginians, sent out by the Ohio Company to erect a "fortified trading-store" at "the forks of the Ohio River," were driven off by the French and returned to their homes, and when three or four hundred Virginia militia-men were forced to return to Virginia after the battle at Fort Necessity they brought word of excellent, well-watered land west of the mountains that would be desirable for settlement. With General Braddock's ill-fated expedition were a number of soldiers from Virginia and Maryland together with one hundred and fifty wagoners from Virginia and from the eastern portion of Pennsylvania. These all confirmed earlier reports of desirable land for settlement when and if the French were driven out. Some of these troops and wagoners were anxious to return when conditions became favorable. The first settler in what is now Jefferson Township in Allegheny County was Zadock Wright, one of Braddock's wagoners.

    [ 11 ]

    Another cause of unrest among the people of Virginia was religious persecution. The Episcopal church was the established or State Church in Virginia. All dissenters were treated harshly. They were arrested and fined for not attending the services of the Episcopal churches. While all dissenters were persecuted, the Baptists were the objects of the bitterest persecution. Not only were Baptists arrested and fined but their pastors were imprisoned for "preaching the Gospel contrary to law." Many Baptists wished to get away from this persecution. They were the type of Baptists who could not be shaken from their denominational loyalty by fines and imprisonments. Rather than give up these loyalties they would face the hardships of pioneering in the wilderness and the chance of being scalped by the Indians. Christians of that type will soon organize churches whei-ever they go. That is just what they did in the southwest corner of Pennsylvania.

    When the French were driven out of the Ohio valley and Fort Pitt was elected at the junction of the Monongahela and Allegheny rivers and Fort Burd at what is now Brownsville; and when the Mason and Dixon line was surveyed and sufficiedtly marked that they could tell when they had crossed from the jurisdiction of the Virginia government these pioneers began their trek over the mountains by the old Braddock road, past the ruins of Fort Necessity and down into the fertile lands of the Monongahela watershed. Immediately at the river the land was too hilly to be desirable so these pioneers built their cabins on the creeks: Redstone Creek, Muddy Creek, Tenmile Creek, Peters Creek, Georges Creek, Simpson Creek, Jacobs Creek, Pigeon Creek, Pattersons Creek and many others. Nearly all of these creeks were destined to give names to Baptist churches. In that day there were no towns, villages or even cross roads to lend names for churches. A creek designated a district and the name of the creek was appropriated as a name for a church in that district.

    In that day of wilderness isolation any one living even a score of miles away was a neighbor and contacts were established between neighbors. These Baptist pioneers soon found one another. All that was needed was leaders to get their together and organized into churches. Rev. Henry Crosbye (Croslye), a Baptist preacher from New Jersey who was affiliated with the Philadelphia Baptist Association, came into the Redstone district and organized the Great Bethel Baptist Church at what is now known as Uniontown on November 7, 1770. Then Rev. John Whitaker came into the Peters Creek district. Rev. John Corbley, after his release from the Culpepper jail in Virginia, where he was imprisoned for "Preaching the Gospel contrary to law," went to Mill Creej in what is now West Virginia and from there to the Muddy Creek district in Pennsylvania. There he organized the Goshen Church in November 1773. In that same month the Peters Creek and Ten Mile Creek Churches were organized. In rapid succession a numbers of other churches were organized. In those churches there were Baptists from Maryland and New Jersey but they were far outnumbered by Baptists from Virginia.

    On Wednesday, Nov. 10, 1773, nine persons, six men and three women, namely, Rev. John Whitaker, Thomas Applegate, Isam Barnet, Henry Lemons, Peter Elrod, Christopher Miller, Mary Whitaker, Margaret Garret and Ailsey Lemons met and organized a Baptist

    [ 12 ]

    (this page not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 13 ]

    (this page not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 14 ]

    (this page not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 15 ]

    (this page not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 16 ]

    fifty years, the walls began to give way under the weight. During the pastorate of Rev. James S Williams, a young man of remarkable energy and qualities of leadership, it was decided to begin the construction of a new church building. It was a time of industrial depression and many men were out of employment or were employed only part time. Many of them were skilled workmen and they volunteered their services, when not otherwise employed, to erect the building themselves. Rev. Williams donned overalls and worked with the volunteers. It was a splendid exhibition of cooperation. The first unit of the building has been completed and has been in use for some time. The funds for completing the work are being secured and it is confidently expected ere long the congregation will be adequately housed again.

    [ 17 ]


    * * * *

    The pastors of the churches that were organized by the pioneer settlers were themselves pioneers, not only in the sense that they were doing pioneer religious work, but they were pioneer settlers. This was a time when money was scarce, in fact rarely seen. The cash part of a pastor's salary was very meager. It had to be supplemented from other sources. Usually these pastors preempted a portion of unclaimed land, elected a log house, or cabin, as it was usually called, and they cleared enough of the land to raise a large part of their provisions and forage for a horse. A saddle horse was quite necessary for covering his wide field and contacting the new settlers that were moving into the district. Game was plentiful and there were no closed seasons on hunting. The pioneer preacher knew how to use a rifle. The members of the church were kind and generous and many times they helped to replenish the pastor's larder. A descendent of Rev. Whitaker, who is now a member of the Peters Creek Church, informs the writer that Rev. Whitaker's claim and cabin were on Peters Creek near the Washington County line. Under the date, March 24, 1778, there is the following entry in the Court records of Washington County, "Rev. John Whitaker, a minister of the Gospel, came into court and took the oath of allegiance as required by the laws of the General Assembly." After the Declaration of Independence all male residents of the Commonwealth, 18 years of age and over, were required to renounce their allegiance to the British government and swear allegiance to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. These laws were enacted to ferret out Tories and other disloyal citizens of the Commonwealth.

    It does not appear that Rev. Whitaker fled from the Indians when they raided this district in 1774, or if he did, it was probably only to cross to the cast side of the Monongahela River where the settlers were not molested. He would be near to give comfort and aid to any families where some of the members had been murdered by the Indians. In 1774 settlers were not venturing into the district, but the next year some who had fled were returning and new families were coming in. Rev. Whitaker's work would consist of establishing contacts with these folks and interesting them in the church.

    With the church covenant is found a notation that in 1775 the church met at five places for Communion service, "Laurel Hill, Corse, The Church at The Forks of the Youghiogheny River, Muddy Creek and Tenmile." This does not mean that the church had members in all these places but that Rev. Whitaker, and possibly one of his deacons, visited these places and held Communion services for the Baptist brethren who were living there, and to promote the organization of churches. On a map of the district under date of 1775 the

    [ 18 ]

    (this page not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 19 ]

    (this page not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    [ 20 ]

    mountain immediately east of places now called Smithfield and Fairchance is named Laurel flill. Baptists from Virginia had settled there. Course may have been in the same district of The Youghiogheny Rivei," was the name sometimes applied to %vhat is now called Confluence, at the junction of the Youghiogheny and Castlemans Rivers with another stream, and also known as Turkey Foot. A Baptist church was organized in 1775 and reported to the Redstone Association the next year as the Turkey Foot Church. Rev. Whitaker's visit there was evidently connected with the organization of that church. Tenmile was the church where the pastor had to flee from the lndians in 1774, and that probably accounts for Rev. Whitaker's presence there for a Communion service in 1775. The order in which the places are named indicates that this missionary tour began on Peters Creek and extended through the Uniontown district to Confluence and back by way of Muddy Creek and Tenmile Creek. Rev. Whitaker evidently made a number of these missionary tours through the district, contacting the new families that were moving in and bringing the ministrations of the church to them when by reason of the distance they could not attend any church service.

    The covenant, signed when the church was organized, differs in wording and in the order of the articles from others in use at that time and evidently was the work of Rev. Whitaker. It indicates he had considerable education and was a clear thinker. He was soundly and sanely orthodox.

    Rev. Whitaker closed his work as pastor at some date in 1780 and went to Kentucky to engage in work there among Baptists from Virginia coming into that district. At a meeting of the Redstone Association in October, 1780, the Yough Church reported but there is no mention of Rev. Whitaker. After this date no church reports under the name Yough. In October, 1781, a church named Peters Creek reports for the first time and the membership is 45, evidently the combined membership of both branches. The messengers were Rev. William Taylor and David Philips, but the title "Rev." is not attached to David Phillips' name. This indicates that Rev. Taylor served for a brief time as pastor or as pulpit supply.

    At this point we may digress to note that there is evidence that for a number of years there was friction and disagreement in the Redstone Association. At some time during this friction the Peters Creek Church either withdrew from the Association or was expelled. Other churches withdrew. At the meeting in 1794 only five churches reported to the Association. The minutes of a number of years are missing and some Minutes recorded without date. This confusion renders it impossible to get information about the church in this period.

    In 1797 conditions evidently improved with 17 churches reporting and in 1800 there were reports from 18 churches but no report from Peters Creek. In 1801 Peters Creek was represented by David Philips, Henry Hulse, and Charles Daily and there is this significant entry in the minutes, "The minister and messengers from Peters Creek make application for admission to the Association." Another statement is, "One brother, Charles Smith, preaching to a crowd outside while

    [ 21 ]

    business goes on inside." That may indicate that the friction was still on.

    Returning to the Peters Creek Church history we note from the Washington County Court Records that in 1783 a petition was presented to the Court by the Peters Creek Church, requesting that a road be constructed from McKee's Ferry to the Peters Creek meeting house. McKee's Ferry was located at what is now called McKeesport and ran between that town and the west bank of the Monongahela River. This road would extend from a point opposite McKeesport to the Peters Creek meeting house on the property of [Robert] Estep Peters Creek. The petition was granted and the road built. This road would enable members of the church living at the junction of the Monongahela and Youghiogheny Rivers to travel to church with greater ease and shows that distance did not greatly hinder church attendance when distances were great and travel mostly on foot.

    Deacon Isaac King in his Centennial history of the church relates that an ancient subscription list, at that time in possession of Mr. E. T. Townsend reads as follows, "We, the under-subscribers, do promise to pay, or cause to be paid, the sums annexed to our names for the use of Rev. David Philips for his labor in the Gospel, and that on or before the first day of March insuing. Witness our hands this second day of May, 1789." The amounts subscribed are in pounds, shillings and pence. This list is interesting as indicating a group of interested and probably influential members of the church at that time. The list is William Philips, Lemual Sayer, Joseph Philips, Samuel Foster, John Masters, Peter Sharp, Richard Masters, Daniel Townsend, Peter Rowletter, Abraham Whitaker, Thomas Rigdon, William Rigdon, and John Mallory. The date of this subscription list, 1789, is the year after the purchase of the building lot from John and Mary Cox at Gastonville and about the time of the occupation of a new house of worship on that lot. A new and better place of worship stimulated new financial interest and liberality. As this was at the time the Peters Creek Church was not making any reports to the Association and evidently not a member of the Association we are unable to get any detailed information about membership and other matters of church interest.

    Deacon Isaac King, citing church records of two business meetings of the congregation in November and December, 1793 and an adjourned meeting January 1, 1794, quotes as follows, "After solemn prayer to Almighty God to direct their choice of a pastor, they unanimously chose David Philips, their former supply, as pastor. And on the same day after an address on The Reciprocal Duties of a pastor and His Church, he accepted the charge of the church." Mr. King adds, "At this period it appears from the record the church owned two houses of worship, one at Elizabeth and another near what is now Finleyville." Mr. King's statement indicates that up to this time Rev. David Philips was the stated supply of the pulpit and at this time became the regular pastor. He further indicates that this call was to be pastor of both branches of the church and that Rev. Philips conducted services in the meeting house at Elizabeth and the other on Peters Creek. At times he also conducted services at Budd's Ferry on the Youghiogheny River. This is the ferry formerly operated by one

    [ 22 ]

    of the constituent members of the church, Peter Elrod. Some Baptists lived at that point. In that day travel was not in a comfortable automobile over paved roads, but on horseback over bad roads and woods trails. Rev. Philips covered many miles of uncomfortable travel in all kinds of weather to meet his preaching appointments and carry on his pastoral work. He would marvel today if he could see the automobiles parked on a Sunday morning at the Peters Creek Church.

    The Anti-Missionary, Anti-Sunday School controversy was the first of three great theological controversies that made trouble for the churches of the district. In the Redstone Baptist Association there were some brethren who held extreme Calvinistic views of the theological doctrine of election. If God had elected any of the heathen or anyone else to be saved, He would save them Himself. This is a lazy and cheap type of theology; just let the Lord do the work and pay the bills. Rev. Philips took no stock in such views and he instructed his congregation in correct views. When the American Baptist Missionary Society was organized in 1815 to care for Adoniram Judson, the missionary, when he arrived in Burma and had become a Baptist, the Peters Creek Church entered into the missionary effort with zeal. The women of the Church organized a Women's Mite Society and in 1817 their offerings for missions surpassed the offerings of all the rest of the Church. The Church has never ceased to be missionary in spirit and has born its full share in all missionary work both on the foreign and the home fields.

    Following close on this first controversy was another, the Campbellite Controversy. Alexander Campbell, a Presbyterian clergyman, came to Washington County about the year 1800. He was a man of marked loyalty to his convictions and opinions and withal had his full share of the Scotch-Irishman's pugnacity. He was out of harmony with Presbyterian teaching and practice and this soon resulted in friction with his Presbyterian brethren. Refusing to adjust his views, to the accepted tenets, of the Presbyterians, he withdrew from that denomination and founded an independent church with doctrines and practices somewhat like the Baptists, but holding views about Baptismal Regeneration and some other tenets alien to Baptists. After two or three years, and perhaps after solicitation by some Baptists, he and his independent church applied to the Redstone Baptist Association for affiliation as a Baptist church. Mr. Campbell and his church were received. This gave him entree to many Baptist churches where he never failed to use the opportunity to expound his theological views. Some Baptist churches were thus thrown into confusion. Among them the Peters Creek Church. However, the Church was fortunate to have as pastor at that time, Rev. David Philips, a man of mature judgment, wide experience, judicial mind and withal quiet firmness. While the Church lost some members who followed Mr. Campbell in the new denomination he founded, Rev. Philips piloted the Church safely through the storm. Though the storm was not yet fully past when he relinquished the pastorate, the influence of his wise leadership kept the Church on an even keel through the rest of the storm.

    The third theological controversy, Mormonism, tied on closely to the previous one. but it produced less disturbance. Sidney Rigdon, a member of the Peters Creek Church, is alleged to have been Joseph Smith's "Angel" or revealer of the golden plates from which the

    [ 23 ]

    Book of Mormon purports to have been compiled, the plates in fact being a manuscript that was purloined from a printing office in Pittsburgh where Rigdon was employed. Anyone seeking additional information on this subject will find it in a pamphlet by Rev. William A. Stanton, D.D., the subject being, "Three Great Theological Controversies."

    By reason of the infirmities of age, Rev. Philips resigned the pastorate in 1824, though he preached occasionally thereafter. His death occurred in 1829. He was regarded as the outstanding preacher of the district, loved and respected by all who knew him. His pastorate was the longest in the history of the church.

    A remnant of the theological storm continued in the period from 1824 to early 1829 and for that reason the Church did not call a regular pastor but was served by pulpit supplies. There were three of these, Revs. Charles Wheeler, John Winter, and Joshua Bradley. This was a wise move, for it gave the Church an opportunity to move slowly and exercise care in the search for a successor to Rev. Philips. While there is no evidence in support of the view, the writer is of the opinion this prudent course resulted from the wise advice of Rev. Philips.

    In March, 1829, Rev. William A. Shadrack was called as pastor. He was a young man with full academic and theological training and had just been ordained at Saltsburg, Pa. This was his first pastorate. He proved to be a preacher of exceptional ability, a clear thinker and a man possessed of talent for leadership. This leadership was demonstrated in the way he handled the theological controversy. At a business meeting of the congregation in August, 1829, the Church at the pastor's suggestion adopted the "Philadelphia Confession of Faith" as the basis of belief and practice by the Church. Dissenters either conformed to this Confession of Faith or found some other group that was more congenial to their views. The six years of Rev. Shadrack's pastorate was one of the prosperous periods in the history of the Church. The old Church building was inadequate and in 1832 a new meeting house of brick construction was erected. This building was located near the north line of the cemetery. At that time labor and materials were cheap; a comfortable and attractive house of worship was erected for the modest sum of twelve hundred and fifty dollars. Later Rev. Shadrack became Field Agent for the new University at Lewisburg, Pa., now known as Bucknell University. In recognition of his meritorious work and scholarship the University conferred on Rev. Shadrack the honorary degree of Doctor of Divinity. For many years he was an outstanding man in the Baptist denomination.

    When a church has had for several years as its pastor a man of unusual abilities both as a preacher and as a leader, difficulty is experienced in finding a satisfactory successor. That seems to have been the condition after the pastorate of Rev. Shadrack. In the next three years the Church was served by two pastors, Rev. William Penny and Rev. Benoni Allen.

    Late in 1838 or early in 1839, Dr. James Estep was called as pastor and served in that capacity for eighteen years, a pastorate second in length of years only to that of Rev. David Philips. Dr. Estep was ordained at the Pigeon Creek Church in October or November of 1805.

    (the remainder of this text not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    The History of
    Peters Cr. Baptist Church

    by Alan Ciechanowski
    (Peters Creek Baptist Church, Library, PA, 1998)

  • Ch. 1: The Covenant
  • Ch. 2: Rev. David Philips
  • Ch. 3: Three Controversies
            Anti Mission Debate
            Campbellite Controversy
            Mormonism Controversy

  • Entire contents copyright © 1998, Peters Creek Baptist Church
    (only limited, "fair use" excerpts are reproduced here)

    [ 1 ]

    Chapter One

    The Covenant

    By wisdom a house is built, and through understanding it is established, -- through knowledge its rooms are filled with rare and beautiful treasures. -- Proverbs 24:3-4

    The covenant agreed upon Entred into & signed by the Church of Jesus Christ Living near the mouth of Yough River Whereas we having given ourselves to the Lord & to one another by the will of God do covenant and agree with each other to walk in all the ordenances & Commandmnts of the Lord Blaimless we do hereby as in the presents of God Almighty SOleMly Linite as a Religious Society to the honour of our God and the Butifiing of his Zion on the Earth and to stand by each other in Maintaining his truth and in Defending the several Doctrines and Rules of Discipline Contained in the Baptst Confession of faith as well as all others warranted in the word of God unto our Lives End.

    With these words, handwritten into an ordinary register book in 1773, what would become the Peters Creek Baptist Church was founded and established. It was a brave and courageous step of faith in what were certainly troubled times. As Settlers and Indians battled and fought in the area all around them, nine people, faithful to the Lord and His Word, began a voyage of faith and fellowship that has so far lasted through more than two centuries, and God willing, will endure through many more.

    In order to more fully understand the times, it will be necessary to look further backward somewhat to the time of the French and Indian War, which began in 1754 and would last a tumultuous five years. Before this time, most settlers had been living east of the Allegheny mountains and had very little knowledge of the lands to the west, among them the areas of Southwestern Pennsylvania. It wasn't until 1755, when General Braddock made his doomed expedition to Fort Duquesne, that the soldiers and civilians accompanying him got their first glimpse of the land that they later described as well-watered, fertile, and favorable for settlement.

    In order to make a settlement there, however, the French had to be driven out of the area, and on this particular mission that would not happen. The French and Indians, using the dense forest for cover, laid in wait for General Braddock's forces, and fell on them before they even reached Fort Duquesne, defeating them and ultimately driving them back to the lands of Maryland and Virginia from which they came.

    At that time, the peoples of Virginia were undergoing what amounted to religious persecution. The Episcopal church was the established, or what was called State Church, in the area, and all those who held differing beliefs were ostracized, even up to imprisonment and fining if they did not attend the services of the Episcopal church. Among those most bitterly persecuted were the Baptists, whose pastors were punished by imprisonment and torture for "preaching the Gospel contrary to law." Many Baptists,

    [ 2 ]

    wanting to flee this religious persecution, opted to strike out for unsettled lands, rather than compromise the faith in which they so strongly believed.

    When the French were finally driven out of Western Pennsylvania by the British, these Virginian Baptists made their way there, risking attacks and scalping by the Indians along the way. With Fort Pitt built where Fort Duquesne once stood, and the Mason-Dixon line drawn up which would mark the line of Virginian influence, the first weary travelers began to settle on the banks of the Monongahela River and its tributaries, including the Youghiogheny, on which the first Peters Creek Baptist Church congregation would eventually meet.

    These settlers began to build their cabins at the foot of hills and mountains and close to the water sources of the surrounding creeks. They built upon Muddy Creek, Ten Mile Creek, Redstone Creek, Georges Creek, Jacobs Creek, Simpsons Creek, Pigeons Creek, Pattersons Creek, and of course, Peters Creek. All these creeks eventually gave their names to Baptist churches, since there were no towns or crossroads after which they could be named.

    In the Redstone area in 1770 a church was organized that came to be known as the Great Bethel Baptist Church of Uniontown. In the Muddy Creek area in November 1773 the Goshen church was organized by Rev. John Corbley, who made his way up after being released front prison in Virginia. In that same month, what would become the Peters Creek Baptist Church was born as well.

    The Covenant, the first paragraph of which appears at the beginning of this chapter (See Appendix A for the complete Covenant) was probably drawn up at the home of Rev. John Whitaker, and was signed by himself and eight other persons, five men and three women, namely, Thomas Applegate, Isam Barret, Henry Lemon, Peter Elrod, Christopher Miller, Mary Whitaker, Margaret Garret, and Ailsey Lemon. It was unusual for that time for the women to be included in the drafting of a document such as this, but since the band of believers was so small, they were included (and rightfully so, since history his since shown that women ire often the stronger of the sexes in matters of faith).

    The Covenant gives no particular name for the church other than as the "church of Jesus Christ living near the mouth of the Yough river." (This would be near what is now McKeesport.) The absence of the name probably indicates that the pioneers had not yet settled on where they would build their meeting house. Their residences were spread out across a distance of several miles, and they were "near the month of the Yough river" only by the standards of their time, where neighbors were often those within a days ride of each other.

    Reverend Whitaker and his wife lived on Peters Creek near the Washington-Allegheny County line; Thomas Applegate near what is now Elizabeth on the Monongahela River; Peter Elrod on the Youghiogheny River five miles north of where it met the Monongahela; the Lemons east of the river; the Garrets in what would now be Peters Township in Washington County, and Isam Barret in Rostraver Township. At the time there were at least five Miller families in the district and it is difficult to tell from which of these families Christopher Miller was from. As his is the last male name to be affixed to the document, it can reasonably be assumed that he was a younger man than the others as tradition would dictate that the eldest and those in the leadership positions sign first.

    [ 3 ]

    Later on, as more believers united with these initial nine, their names would also be affixed to the Covenant. In fact, two names appear on December 26 of that year, Morris Brady and John Garret. It is not until the years 1775 and 1776 that any other names are recorded.

    With the members so spread out from one another, it seems only fitting that they would begin to meet in different locations throughout the region. Four places are mentioned in the first of the "meeting minutes" (dated September 30, 1775). They are Laurel Hill, Muddy Creek, Ten Mile Creek, and the Church at the Fords of the Youghiogheny River. It was this river which would give the church its first name, for at a meeting held in the region on October 5, 1778, the name of Rev. John Whitaker appears as a representative of the Yough Church along with the name of Stephen Ashby, whose name was appended to the Covenant on July 7, 1776.

    It may seem strange to us that no names were appended to the Covenant in the year of 1774, yet an understanding of the times brings the reasons to light. During that year, the Indians began a campaign of savage attacks against the settlers. Those who lived east of the Monongahela River were largely untouched, for they were viewed as Pennsylvanians by the Indians, and for them they held no ill will. It was with the Virginians living on the west banks of the river that they had their problems, seeing them as the enemy during the French and Indian War. These settlers feared for their lives, and they began to leave their settlements in droves and cross to the east side of the Monongahela and to safety. History records that in one day two hundred people crossed that river in order to protect their lives and families. Even the pastors of the churches in the area would flee, though no record of Rev. Whitaker ever having left the area seems to be present.

    Thus, the opportunities for church meeting and expansion were few, and it wasn't until some time later that the little church that began on a cold November evening in 1773 would begin to meet regularly and begin to draw others into its committed circle of believers.

    One other event would leave its mark on the church, as well as the rest of the world, at the time. On December 13, 1773, just a little over a month after the signing of the Covenant, a group of Colonists in Boston, tired of the taxation of the Colonies by the British Crown, staged a rebellion known as the Boston Tea Party. This event brought about a slow rolling boil of both the Colonies and the British Empire until on April 18, 1775, the night of Paul Revere's ride in Lexington, the first shots of the American Revolution would be fired. While only eight Americans would die this night, many more would soon follow as the Colonies began to fight for their independence.

    Men from the region appear as members of the company of Captain William Fife, Second Battalion of the Washington County Militia. Some of those names would later show up on the rolls of the Peters Creek Baptist Church: John Boyer, David Philips, William Philips, Henry Hulse, and William Rigdon among others. These men patrolled the western border between Pittsburgh and Wheeling.

    Finally, in the year 1776, things began to settle down and the church began to meet regularly. One historian of Westmoreland County notes that in that year there was a log meeting-house on the property of Benjamin Applegate, one of the brothers of Thomas Applegate who signed the original Covenant. As there was no other church in the area at that time, it seems reasonable to assume that this was the first meeting-house of what would become Peters Creek Baptist Church.

    [ 4 ]

    It is interesting to take a look at some of the meeting minutes that have survived from that time:

    April the 6 1776

    Being met together, Peter Elrod being cold before the church concerning selling a certain tract of land and marking of hogs and concerning a horse of which the church is satisfied.

    Likewise our Brother John Jackman was cold to answer some accusations laid against him which the body of the church was not satisfied with

    June the 1

    He having seen his folly made confession was received.

    What the marking of hogs had to do with the business of the church is a mystery from our perspective, but we can be assured that it was of the utmost importance in its day.

    The little meeting-house on the Applegate property was on the east side of the Monongahela River at Elizabeth. As the settlers began to return to their properties on the West Side of the river (after the Indians had been defeated and moved further westward), getting to church on the opposite side of the unbridged river would prove difficult. In 1778 this dilemma would be solved through the building of a second church on the property of Robert Estep near the present site of Gastonville. It was a log building closer to the home of its pastor, Rev. Whitaker, and situated on the banks of Peters Creek.

    It was shortly after this, in the year 1780, that Captain David Philips, one of the men listed as part of the Second Battalion of Washington County, was received into the church by letter (meaning a transfer of membership from another church). He rose steadily and fast in the congregation, for on the same day he was received, September 1, 1780, he was chosen as one of the representatives of the church to the meeting of the Redstone Association, the Baptist Association of the district at that time. He also helped to write a letter to that same association (apparently to request the church's membership in it) as well as become a deacon, all on the same clay!

    In 1781, David Philips was ordained as a minister of the Gospel and served as one of the pulpit supply ministers of the churches within the Redstone Association. Ill the next few years, he would travel on horseback or on foot to churches throughout the Monongahela valley to preach and to serve communion. Also in 1781, the church, known until now as the Yough Church, made what would amount to be a landmark decision in retrospect. In an entry to the minutes dated January 6, 1781, it would be agreed that
    the transaction of this Church as corresponding with other Churches from abroad is hereafter to bear the title of the Church

    And so it was that the church founded eight years earlier on November 10, 1773, would finally come to bear the name of the creek on which it now rested. Even though it would move from the creek in later years, it would retain the name as long as its people retained the vision of what the church was and would eventually become -- a place where man could worship the one true God, and serve Him faithfully until their "live's end."

    [ 5 ]

    Chapter Two

    Rev. David Phillips

    But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well. -- Matt 6:33

    The exact nature of the Reverend John Whitaker's separation from the Yough Church is largely unknown. Some records indicate that the land titles of many settlers west of the Monongahela River were invalidated because of a Treaty entered into by a George Groghan that basically gave him the right to much of the land in the area. It is possible that the Reverend Whitaker's land was included, and induced him to take the opportunity to move on. What is known is that a party of over 1000 people on 63 flat boats left the Monongahela on April 1, 1781, headed for Kentucky. Included in that party was John Whitaker and much of his family, including spouses of many of his children and several of his grandchildren.

    It seems quite fortuitous, then, that later that year, this church would be one of the churches at which David Philips began to preach. It seems absolutely providential, however, when we find that he would serve this church as its preacher, leader, and pastor, for the next 43 years. His would be the longest tenure of any subsequent pastor of the church thus far. (See Appendix B for a complete list of pastors.)

    David Philips was born the son of Joseph Philips in 1742 in Cilcam, Pembrokeshire, in South Wales. He emigrated with his family in 1755 and settled in Chester County, Pennsylvania, near what is now Philadelphia. His family became integral members of the Great Valley Baptist Church, the second oldest Baptist church in Pennsylvania (founded on April 22, 1711). This church spawned a branch in 1737 known as the Vincent Baptist Church, originally built not more than 200 yards from its mother church.

    In the year 1771, based on requests of the members and after much prayer, many members of the Great Valley Baptist Church were dismissed to become members of the Vincent Baptist Church, which for some years now had been an independent church with its own governing body. Among these members appear seven members of the Philips family: Joseph Philips and his wife Mary, David and his wife Mary, David's brother John and his wife Margaret, and David's other brother Josiah.

    As mentioned in the previous chapter, David Philips joined in the colonies' effort to free themselves from the tyranny of "taxation without representation" and became a Captain in the Second Company of the Seventh Regiment of Militia during the American Revolution. His brothers Josiah, John and youngest brother Joseph, were also found in this company.

    In 1780, David headed west with the same pioneer spirit that brought his family to America not many years earlier. With him were his wife and children, Benjamin (14),

    [ 6 ]

    John (12), Thomas (6), Josiah (4), and possibly David, who was born on the April 1, 1780. In September of that year, he would join the small band of Baptists known as the Yough Church, and would immediately be accepted as a man of great faith, leadership ability, and strength.

    David Philips was 38 years old when he came to settle in Washington County. As far as anyone knows, he had no formal education in theology or ministry. What he did have was an excellent command of the English language (having spent some time in his youth teaching the children in the common schools), and a natural leadership ability (evidenced by his promotion to Captain during the Revolutionary War). He was also gifted with an almost instinctive ability to fill the spiritual needs of the people, which may have been a result of his family's strong faith and their experience in the Great Valley and Vincent Baptist Churches they had been a part of.

    In November of 1780, David Philips was nominated to act as an Elder in the Yough Church upon "trial," a type of probationary period in which his performance in that respect would be tested and finally approved. On January 6 1781, the same day that the name of the church was changed to the Church Upon Peters Creek, the meeting minutes allude to a letter that "Brother Philips" signed then read to "Brother Whitaker." It is believed that this might be the letter which Rev. Whitaker would take with him when he left for Kentucky later that year. Shortly thereafter, in April 1781, David Philips would become known as Reverend David Philips, as he was ordained and began his life as an itinerant preacher in the area served by the Redstone Association.

    Almost from its inception, the Church Upon Peters Creek seemed to be burdened by division and strife. In the meeting minutes of the time, there is a continuing tale of one James Sparks. He was baptized in November 1780, and in January of the following year, is accused of "great misconduct." The church "proceeded to admonish him, and have suspended him from Communion, until his repentance for his sin appears and satisfaction thereupon given to the Church." In March, the minutes show him as still unrepentant, and in July, he is further accused of drinking and fighting. September still finds that the "fruits of Godly sorrow" are not present with him. It isn't until November of 1781 that "James Sparks upon profession of his repentance was restored to fellowship." Yet, in January of 1782 his name appears again in the minutes, this time accused of "profane and blasphemous expressions and of dancing."

    In these same minutes, another controversy bolls between Henry and Ailsey Lemon and Brother Hall. 'I'he details here are more vague, but would show up in various places from January 1780 until the same time one year later. It would finally end with all three restored into the church and full communion.

    If ever a church needed a Godly pastor and leader, it was the Church Upon Peters Creek, and God provided 'ust that in the person of Rev. David Philips.

    A sketch of David Philips was written by Isaac King, a deacon of the church circa 1875. He paints a picture of a man infused with energy and anointed of God to preach:
    (He) was a man of peculiar commanding appearance, especially in the pulpit. (He was a) large man of beamitig and pleasing countenance. In the matter of his pulpit production the hearer would involuntarily assent that his heart was deeply impressed with the subject of his message to his audience. Having the doctrine of Man's Lost condition by nature deeply enstampt on his heart and conscience by the Grace of God, he was amply ready to enforce it by the

    [ 7 ]

    corresponding testimony of God's Holy Word. When he would dwell upon the solemn theme his hearers would sometimes be brought to tears of deep penitence. He was just as well qualified by (an) experienced and well-versed mind in a knowledge of God's Word to satisfy the craving of the sinsick soul by presenting the Love of God to man in the gift of his dear son as a sacrificial offering for the redemption of souls. Dwelling on that theme of all themes his tongue would dwell on the soul cheering promise of God's Word to the edification and strengthening of the faith of all true believers. The Grace of God in Christ was the anchor that held him hard by the cross of Calvary as his hearers would readily admit whether they had received that grace or no. As a pulpit Orator, Rev. Philips was the equal if not the superior of a sonorous voice quite pleasing and of great compass, being deeply impressed with his subject.

    Rev. Philips preached not only at the Peters Creek church, but, as previously stated, at churches throughout the region. Some of these churches were private dwellings, some meeting-houses, but all undoubtedly log buildings whose windows opened to the outside. Isaac King remembers sitting in one of these buildings on a cold winter day, and though there was no stove or fire to warm the congregation, they listened to "a warm sermon which seemed to do their souls as much good as if their bodies had been resting on cushioned and luxurious pews in a ceiled house."

    At the meeting of the Redstone Association in October of 1781, The Church Upon Peters Creek appears for the first time with a membership figure of 45 persons, which wasa combined total of the two meeting houses, at Gastonville and at Elizabeth. The messengers for this meeting are listed as Rev. William Taylor and David Philips. The title of Reverend was not appended to Philips' name here, which may be an indication of his status as an itinerant preacher in the entire area. Rev. Taylor was possibly a more regular pulpit supply minister and was, in fact, one of those instrumental in ordaining David Philips to the ministry.

    The meeting minutes for the Philips' years do not seem to have survived the passing of time, but from several other records it is possible to reconstruct some of the major events in the life of the church.

    In the Washington County Court Records in 1783 a petition written by the "Peters Creek Church" appears proposing that a road be constructed from "McKees Ferry to the Peters Creek Meeting House." This would be from what is now McKeesport to the present site of Gastonville on Peters Creek. This petition was granted, a road was built, and from that point on, the small but fervent congregation of the Peters Creek Baptist Church would find it easier to get to services regardless of the great distances they would have to travel.

    Some years afterward, Rev. Philips made firm his intentions to settle in the Peters Creek area for some time:

    Know ye that in consideration of the monies paid by Reverend David Philips into the Receiver Generals Office of this commonwealth at the granting of the warrant herein after mentioned and of the further sum of Eleven pounds thirteen shillings and eight pence paid by the said David Philips into the said office, there is granted by the said Commonwealth unto the said David Philips, a certain Tract of Land called "Nineveh" Situate on the waters of Peters Creek in the County of Washington.

    [ 8 ]

    Rev. Philips had bought a piece of land which would be marked in the patent (from which the above is taken) as "beginning at a White Oak," heading north so many degrees and perches to a black oak, and so on, being marked by Walnut trees, Hickories and other objects of nature, until the line is drawn back to the beginning. (The complete patent can be found in Appendix C.)

    It was around this time that deeds and patents were being written up giving formal ownership to the settlers for the land on which they had settled. The property on which both of the Peters Creek churches now stood became the legal property of other people, and the church decided to buy a piece of land that would be owned outright by the church itself. This dream became a reality on September 10, 1788, as recorded in the Deed Book of Washington County, when a little over five acres was sold to Peters Creek Baptist Church by John and Mary Cox. It is described as bordering on Peters Creek a distance of eight rods, and would also be in the vicinity of Gastonville. On this land another log building, larger and more comfortable than the one on the Estep property or in Elizabeth, was built, and served Peters Creek Baptist Church for some 20 years.

    In 1789 the people of Peters Creek Baptist Church subscribed their names to a document outlining the remuneration David Philips would receive for his service:
    We the under-subscribers, do promise to pay or cause to be paid the sums annexed to our names for the use of the Rev. David Philips for his labor in the Gospel and that on or before the first day of march ensuing. Witness our hands this second day of May 1789.

    William Philips 0 0
    Lemuel Sayer 2 0 0
    Joseph Philips 1 0 0
    Samuel Foster 1 0 0
    John Masters _ 7 6
    Peter Sharp 1 4 _
    Richard Masters 1 0 0
    Daniel Townsend 2 0 0
    Peter Rowletter 1 0 0
    Abram Whitaker 1 0 0
    Thomas Rigdon 1 0 0
    William Rigdon 0 12 0
    John Mallory 0 6 0
    As a result of this agreement in 1789, Rev. David Philips received the equivalent of only thirty dollars in today's currency as a salary.

    Many of the prior histories of the church refer to a "revival" at Peters Creek in the year 1793 which extended the membership to 45 persons. As the membership in 1781 was also 45, it is unclear if there was a period of membership drop between the two, or whether this number was just the membership at the Gastonville branch of the church.

    On January 1, 1794, the church met to select a permanent pastor. Thus far, they had been served by David Philips as well as other pulpit supply ministers. With the

    [ 9 ]

    increase in membership, however, the church now considered the election of a full time pastor. Deacon Isaac King records this in his 1875 sketch of Rev. Philips:
    After several meetings the church appointed the first day of January 1794 to select a pastor; they met accordingly and after Solemn Prayer to Almighty God for Divine Grace accepted, and shortly after the branch at Elizabeth unanimously concurred, and both appear afterwards to have united as one consolidated church with Rev. David Philips as pastor.

    Rev. Philips became a man of great influence and prestige, not only in the church, but in the political world as well. He often served in public positions and was, at one point, appointed by Washington County as a member of a committee to confer with Congress. He served on this committee with Albert Gallatin, who served as a Secretary of the Treasury for twelve years under Presidents Madison and Jefferson.

    This influence would be called upon during the very first year of his full-time pastorate at Peters Creek. Three years before, in 1791, Congress adopted Alexander Hamilton's proposal to begin collecting an excise tax on distilled spirits. For the people of this area, that meant some hard times, for the distillation of grain was a staple of the farmers income. They became aggravated and rebellious, and this rebellion seethed until it finally reached its apex in the summer of 1794.

    General John Neville was at this time the revenue collector for Bedford, Washington, Westmoreland, and Allegheny Counties, and was responsible for collecting the excise tax. On July 15 he issued a warrant ordering a local distiller, William Miller of nearby Mingo Creek, to appear before the district court for refusing to pay the tax. This sparked the uprising that came to be known as the Whiskey Rebellion. On July 16, 500 discontented farmers began to march on General Neville's country estate at Bower Hill. They demanded Neville's resignation, and when they were refused it, they began to shoot. Major James McFarlane, the leader of the rebellion, was killed by a bullet, and, in retaliation, his compatriots set fire to the buildings on Neville's estate.

    Emotions continued to rise in the area until August 1st, when several thousand men assembled at Braddock's field, all set to destroy the fledgling city of Pittsburgh in a show of solidarity and rebellion. They were stopped only by the eloquence of Hugh Henry Brackenridge, a Pittsburgh lawyer, who persuaded the men that many of them would die in the attempt. The day passed without incident.

    Throughout this time, the churches in the area tried to keep the peace. Their pastors preached against the evils of alcohol and rebellion, and called for their congregations to submit to the authority of the government, no doubt quoting 1 Peter 2:13 in the process. Rev. Philips was appointed to do more, and he went to Pittsburgh as part of a committee to talk to officials about having the tax repealed. Though this effort failed, the tax was lowered to one-quarter of the original amount and finally, after much struggle and persuasion, the farmers began to uphold the government's tax and peace once again came to Peters Creek and the surrounding area.

    Some time after this came a truly historic moment for the peoples of Peters Creek Baptist Church. On October 6, 1797, Rev. David Philips sold one acre of his beloved Nineveh to the Peters Creek Baptist Church for the sum of five pounds, stating that the property was to remain in the Baptist denomination or be sold. Although more land has

    [ 10 ]

    been added to the original tract since that time, it is on this land that Peters Creek Baptist Church stands today.

    It took several years, however, before a church building would be built on this land. The church still worshipped at two sites: Peters Creek and Elizabeth. It can be safely assumed that there was some concern and dissension among church members on the proposed location of the new church. Since the roads in those days were barely passable at times, people living in the more outreaching areas found it hard to travel to the land granted by Rev. Philips in the area then known as Loafer's Hollow.

    It wasn't until 1810 that Peters Creek Baptist Church would finally make its move. In a deed dated April 10, 1810, we find that the property on Peters Creek was sold by the church to James Gaston. The proceeds of this sale were used to erect the first log church on the Philips property. This church was actually a log addition to the home of Rev. Philips and served the church for 22 years. (A pew from this building, hewn and hand-made from black walnut trees, resides in the church museum even today.)

    In this manner, the Peters Creek Baptist Church could no longer be called the Church Upon Peters Creek, for it no longer sat on the creek for which it was named, but was now closer to one of its tributaries, the Piney Fork creek.

    In this small, unassuming church, would brew three great controversies that would eventually touch not only the Peters Creek church but the world at large. We turn to these in the following chapter.

    [ 11 ]

    Chapter Three

    Three Controversies

    For the time will come when men will not put up with sound doctrine. Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to bear. -- 2 Timothy 4:3

    In any church in the world, today, tomorrow, or at any time in the past, there is bound to be disagreement, conflict, and dissolution. It is a sad commentary on our nature as fallen humans that it is so. It is a joyful commentary on the grace of God that these troubles eventually pass and usually leave us stronger and more steadfast in our faith. The ingredients necessary to bring about that resolution are utter faithfulness to the Word of God, prayer, and a humble seeking after God's will. In Rev. Philips later years, he found it necessary to call upon all these techniques to calm the storms that began to rage through Peters Creek Baptist Church and the community that surrounded it. Three great controversies rocked the church during this time and would eventually leave permanent marks on the church as well as the rest of the world. We discuss them here as they appeared.

    The Anti-Missionary, Anti-Sunday School Debate

    In the early 1800's, not only Peters Creek, but all the churches of the Redstone Association were shaken by a controversy that today is a non-issue. On May 18, 1814, the General Missionary Convention of the Baptist Denomination in the United States of America for Foreign Missions was organized in Philadelphia, PA. This convention marked the beginning of missions work among Baptist churches. It would take some time, however, for all Baptist churches to come to terms with this new direction for their denomination.

    At a meeting of the Redstone Association held at Peters Creek in 1815, a debate ensued concerning the doctrine of election. Some pastors argued that support for missionaries was a violation of God's intent for the church. In their extreme views, if God wanted the heathen saved, He would save them Himself. It seems they had forgotten the works of Paul on his missionary journeys, or Christ's commandment to "go into all the world and preach the gospel to all people."

    Rev. Philips would have none of this, however. A few years earlier, in 1812, he was among the first to establish the First Baptist Church at Fort Pitt in Pittsburgh. In addition, the church at Peters Creek had already begun to support the call of God upon John Mason Peck, who was led to spread the gospel among the Indian populace.

    [ 12 ]

    Rev. Philips knew the importance of missionary work and he stood up at the 1815 meeting to help his fellow pastors to understand the same.

    Some listened, learned, and began to adopt the policy of mission support in their churches. Some, however, would go so far as to withdraw their churches from the Association. In doing so, they missed out on the first opportunities to support Adoniram Judson, who later became legendary in his missionary zeal at his station in Burma, India.

    The leadership of Rev. Philips inspired the women at Peters Creek Baptist Church to form the Women's Mite Society for the benefit of missions. The Society women walked many miles in their petticoats and bonnets soliciting support for the Baptist missionaries abroad. At times they scarcely collected pocket change, but in 1817 they made a collection that surpassed the entire offering of the church at the time. At some point, the Women's Mite Society seems to disappear from the church records. In 1881, however, a Woman's Missionary Union again appears in the records. It seems as if truly a woman's work is never done.

    A lesser debate seems to have raged concerning Sunday School as well. This time, the argument was "If the Lord wants them to learn, He will teach." One wonders if the pastors who made these arguments ever attended school as a child, for a reasonable progression of this thinking would be that if the Lord wanted a child to learn reading or arithmetic, He would teach that as well.

    The Campbellite Controversy

    The next issue to fall upon the church would leave an even greater mark upon it, ultimately dividing it and causing the loss of some of its members.

    In 1807 a man by the name of Rev. Thomas Campbell emigrated to the United States from Scotland. He settled in this area and joined the Presbyterian church as a member of the Presbytery of Chartiers. Almost immediately, a whirlwind of controversy encircled him within the denomination as he remonstrated against the creeds, confessions, and catechisms of the church. It was his opinion that man had added too much to the simple Gospel of Christ. In 1809 at a meeting held in Washington County, Campbell was instrumental in forming the Christian Association of Washington "for the sole purpose of promoting simple evangelical Christianity, free from all mixture of human opinions and inventions of men."

    In 1810 at a meeting of the Synod of the Presbyterian Church, Rev. Campbell applied as a representative of this new association for ministerial standing within the Synod. Rev. Campbell was heard at length but the Synod unanimously resolved that

    however specious the plan of the Christian Association, and however seducing its professions, as experience of the effects of similar projects in other parts has evinced their baleful tendency and destructive operations on the whole interests of religion by promoting divisions instead of union, by degrading the ministerial character, by providing free admission to any errors in doctrine, and to any corruptions in discipline, whilst a nominal approbation of the Scriptures as the only standard of truth may be professed, the synod are constrained to disapprove the plan and its natural effects.

    [ 13 ]

    Rev. Campbell's association, having not met the standards of the Presbyterian church, found itself excluded from it. Consequently, in 1811, the Christian Association of Washington was organized into an independent church with "no other creed but the Bible." Thomas Campbell was appointed elder and his son, Alexander, was licensed by the association to preach the Gospel in that same year.

    Thomas and Alexander Campbell eventually came to find that their views were closely linked to those of the Baptist church. They saw the Baptist doctrines of baptism by immersion, and the Bible as the only source of all teaching as directly linked with their own beliefs. Alexander Campbell was baptized by a Baptist minister in June of 1812 and it wasn't very long after that, in 1813, that Campbell's church became a member of the Redstone Association of Baptist Churches.

    This allowed the Campbells to preach in the churches of the Association, and Alexander Campbell frequently did just that. On many occasions he could be found preaching at any of the several churches in the area, among them Peters Creek Baptist Church, and there would expound on his views of spiritual regeneration and baptism. It is at this point that confusion began to be sown, for Campbell's doctrine was that baptism was directly connected with the promise of the remission of sins, and could not thus be separated from the salvation experience of any Christian. Without baptism by immersion, he would argue, a soul cannot be saved unto the kingdom of Christ.

    Rev. Philips fought this doctrine earnestly, and his powerful speech and careful exegesis of Scripture ultimately saved the Peters Creek church from spiritual destruction. In spite of his best efforts, however, in 1815 some members were lost to the "Campbellite" church. Though the worst of it had passed by this time, ripples of the waves continued to wash up on the shore of Peters Creek for some time to come.

    In 1824 Rev. Philips was forced to give up the pastorate of Peters Creek Baptist Church. Though it must have grieved his heart to do so, old age had begun to take its toll on his body and he was unable to continue the rigorous schedule of the pastorate. He would preach only a few times thereafter until his death in 1829.

    Rev. Philips was respected and loved by all who knew him and his loss was a great blow to the still fledgling church. He had had a large family, and today his descendants now number in the thousands. Some would go on to preach the gospel, and many would stay on to worship at Peters Creek. As of this writing, there are still descendants of Rev. Philips attending Peters Creek Baptist Church.

    After the resignation of Rev. Philips, the church was served by a number of pulpit supplies. Revs. Charles Wheeler, John Winter, and Joshua Walker were among these. J. G. Lauderbaugh, in his 1948 history of the church, suggested that this was a direct result of Rev. Philips' insistence that the church not choose a successor until they could feel comfortable that the candidate held the right views of regeneration and baptism. The Campbellite controversy continued to rage, and so it wasn't until March 1829 that the church finally called William Shadrach to the pastorate.

    William Shadrach had just been ordained at Saltsburg, PA, when he was called to Peters Creek Baptist Church to serve his first pastorate. Lauderbaugh describes him as a "preacher of exceptional ability, a clear thinker and a man possessed of talent for leadership." That talent would be necessary, for by 1835 Shadrach recognized that the dissension and confusions within the church had reached a boiling point and he called a meeting to clear up the doctrinal misunderstandings.

    [ 14 ]

    At the meeting, he suggested they form a committee to draft articles of faith that would exclude the adoption of any of Campbell's heresies. The motion was carried, and Shadrach, along with Enoch Wright, Daniel VanVoorhis, Jacob Boyer, and Edward Riggs, became this committee. Four articles of faith were the result of this committee. Briefly, they were:

    1) That salvation comes not just from understanding the word of God, but by its active application, and that no one comes to Christ accept by the will and grace of God;

    2) That the Holy Spirit does actively work in the world today to procure the redemption of sinners;

    3) That baptism does not procure salvation but is a symbol to the community of a person's saved state, and

    4) That regeneration is the change procured when one believes ill the death of Jesus Christ for the payment of personal sins, and wishes to walk with Christ in every detail of life.

    The articles (which appear in their entirety in Appendix E), Were signed by everyone on the committee but Edward Riggs. He did not believe the church had the right to proscribe any article against the teaching of Alexander Campbell, nor did he believe that the articles were in any way a contradiction of Campbell's beliefs. Be that as it may, however, the articles were drafted by the church on February 20, 1836. They were affixed to the original church covenant and signed by a minority of the members of the church. A majority refused to commit themselves to the articles, and were thus requested to seek membership in a church more sympathetic to their views. The signing minority took control of the church, going so far as to remove and replace the locks to the church so that those who had not signed would be barred from fellowship until they did.

    Edward Riggs, probably because of his very active dissension, was one of the first to be disowned from the church. Soon thereafter, many of the members that had stood on that side of the fence with him were reconciled to the church. Riggs, along with James Boyer, Samuel Blackmore, Henry Bennett, Sarah Moore, and Sarah Philips began to meet as a Disciples of Christ congregation at Riggs home, under the leadership of David Newmyre, and when Campbell visited this church, he set Riggs up as elder. This church became part of what would come to be known as the Disciples of Christ, or Christian, Church.

    Sometime later, Rev. Shadrach also appended to the original covenant and the four articles a statement of faith which was similar to the Philadelphia Confession of Faith, a Baptist statement of faith drafted in London in 1869. This would ensure that the Peters Creek Baptist Church congregation had no doubt as to what it was they believed, and why they believed it. It would also, for the most part, put to an end the Campbellite controversy's effect on the church.

    The Mormonism Controversy

    The next controversy was really not a controversy at the time it was happening, but in retrospect, is so intriguing that we will devote some space to it here, for it seems that the Mormon religion may have been birthed by a member of Peters Creek Baptist Church.

    Sidney Rigdon was born in Library in 1793 and came to join the Peters Creek church in 1817. In the following years, he studied divinity in Beaver County, and by 1822

    [ 15 ]

    he had become pastor of the First Baptist Church in Pittsburgh. A little more than a year later, he was expelled from the Baptist denomination for preaching "doctrinal errors," and became part of the Campbellite Church. In 1826 he moved to Ohio to join the Mormon Church. This is the account of his life as some believe it, but other theories exist that seem to embellish, and at times contradict, it.

    Solomon Spaulding, a Presbyterian minister who, for health reasons, was forced into an early retirement, settled in Ashtabula County, Ohio, and began to write a historical romance replete with religious allegories. The story began to grow and take form and he would read each new chapter to his neighbors as it was finished. The characters of his book came alive for the hearers of the story and they would anxiously await each new installment. When it was finally finished, he was encouraged to have it published, and in 1812 he finally moved to Pittsburgh in the hope that in that city his dream would be realized. He took the manuscript to the printing office of H.J. [sic - R. & J.?] Patterson to see if it could be made ready for publication. For some unknown reason, it never was made ready, and was never published. If it had been published, it is quite possible that Mormonism may have never taken form, and become the presence it is today.

    The theory that many historians support is that Sidney Rigdon came across Spaulding's manuscript and, along with Joseph Smith, used it as a basis for the Book of Mormon. There are a number of reasons that this theory has been proposed, and I refer to the History of Washington County by Boyd Crumrine to touch on a few.

    John Spaulding, brother of Solomon, and his wife Martha were among the first to hear Solomon's story, which he titled Manuscript Found. They remember that it fictitiously reported to be a manuscript discovered near Conneaut, Ohio, and that its principle characters went by the names of Nephi and Lehi. These characters were eventually divided over quarrels and arguments and their descendants eventually became known as Nephites and Lamanites. These names, and some of the same history appears in the Book of Mormon. The phrase "and it came to pass" was frequently used in Solomon Spaulding's manuscript and was remembered by many people who heard or read the original story. This phrase is also used frequently in the Book of Mormon.

    A curious error appears in both manuscripts as well. In the First Book of Nephi, Nephi says they "did speak many hard words unto us, their younger brothers, and they did smite us even with a rod." At this point an angel appears and says, "Why do ye smite your younger brother with a rod?" It is interesting that the word brother appears both in its singular form and plural form in this passage, as consistency would suggest use of one or the other. Yet that same inconsistency shows up both in Manuscript Found and the Book of Mormon, and seems proof positive of plagiarism.

    Many people who heard or read Manuscript Found were immediately reminded of it as they came across the Book of Mormon or the Golden Bible, as it was referred to for some time. They not only remembered the names of principle characters like Nephi, Lehi, Moroni, and others, they even recognized the plot of the book as a whole. Neighbors of Spaulding's remember that the story told of the first settlers of America, long before the time of Columbus. These settlers came from Jerusalem and became known to us as Indians. Their laws, manners, customs, wars, and travels were well documented in Spaulding's book and came to appear, verbatim at times, in the Book of Mormon. Added to it was much Scripture and other material, but it was not enough to hide Spaulding's work within it.

    [ 16 ]

    Yet how did Sidney Rigdon come across this manuscript and transform it into the Book of Mormon. Two theories exist here. One is that Rigdon was a printer at Patterson's printing shop when Spaulding brought Manuscript Found there in 1812. Though at a time this theory was the most widely accepted, there are a number of respected citizens who deny that Rigdon ever resided in Pittsburgh prior to his pastorate there in 1822. Among those who make these claims are two past members of Peters Creek Baptist Church, Isaac King and Peter Boyer.

    The more likely theory is that during the time that Sidney Rigdon pastored the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh, he came across the manuscript in any one of a number of ways. The most frequently proposed, and most highly substantiated, is that it came into Rigdon's possession through a man named J. Harrison Lambdin, who at one time was a partner at Patterson's print shop, and who eventually was known to be good friends with Sidney Rigdon. If Spaulding's manuscript remained unprinted and unpublished, its unique contention to be an ancient manuscript recounting the history of the American Indian would have made it an intellectual curiosity and one to be salvaged from what may have been many manuscripts lying about the printing office.

    One piece of evidence in the favor of this theory also has a connection with Peters Creek Baptist Church. Rev. John Winter, who served as a pulpit supply at Peters Creek for a short time recalled being in Rigdon's study in 1822-23. Rigdon pulled a large manuscript from his desk and told Winter that a Presbyterian minister by the name of Spaulding had written it and had taken it to the printer to get it published. He termed it a romance of the Bible. Winter did not read it, but remembered the incident when he heard that Spaulding's wife recognized her husband's writings in the book of Mormon.

    Mrs. Amos Dunlop wrote in an answer to an inquiry made of her in 1879 that she often visited the Rigdon family when she was a child. She recalls Sidney Rigdon taking a manuscript from a trunk and reading it one time when she was present. His wife, irritated at finding him so compelled, told him she meant to burn the manuscript someday. Rigdon replied that she would not for it would become a great thing some day. It is questionable if even Rigdon knew what great thing it would Eventually become, but it is apparent that he had some sort of a plan for it.

    It wasn't until Rigdon made the acquaintance of Joseph Smith, however, that the plan began to take form. in the summer of 1827, many neighbors of Joseph Smith began to notice the frequent visits of a "mysterious stranger" to Smith's. It eventually became known that the stranger was Sidney Rigdon, described by one person as a "backsliding clergyman ... a Campbellite preacher in Mentor, Ohio." His neighbors from that town also recalled that Rigdon would spend weeks at a time away from his home in the winter before the publication of the Book of Mormon.

    A letter was published in Campbell's Millennial Harbinger in 1844 by a brother-in-law of Rigdon's. He claimed that Rigdon had knowledge of a book which had been found engraved on gold plates in New York and was being made ready for publication, long before the book of Mormon came to the public eye. This allegation is echoed by many others who were acquaintances of Rigdon in the late 1820's.

    It seems strange that one who once professed Christ and was baptized in the church could purposefully lead others astray when it came to the Gospel. Yet a number of quotes respond to that by showing us some of the character of Sidney Rigdon from the beginning:

    [ 17 ]

    He professed to experience a change of heart when a young man, and proposed to join the church under the care of Elder David Philips. But there was so much miracle about his conversion, and so much parade about his profession that the pious and discerning pastor entertained serious doubts at the time in regard to the genuineness of the work. He was received, however, by the church and baptized by the pastor, with some fears and doubts upon his mind. Very soon, Diotrephes-like, he began to put himself forward and seek the pre-eminence, and was well- nigh supplanting the tried and faithful minister who had reared and nursed and fed the church a long series of years. So thoroughly convinced was Father Philips by this time that he was not possessed of the spirit of Christ, notwithstanding his miraculous conversion and flippant speech, that he declared his belief 'that as long as he (Sidney) should live, he would be a curse to the church of Christ.' -- Samuel Williams, Mormonism Exposed, 1842

    When Holland Sumner dealt with Rigdon for his bad teachings, and said to him, 'Brother Rigdon, you never got into a Baptist Church without relating your Christian experiences,' Rigdon replied, 'When I joined the church at Peters Creek I knew I could not be admitted without an experience, so I made one up to suit the purpose; but it was all made up, and was of no use, nor true.' This I have just copied from an old memorandum, as taken from Sumner himself. Rev. Winter, The Baptist Witness, January 1875.

    Sidney Rigdon, when quite a boy, living with his father some fifteen miles south of Pittsburgh on a farm, was thrown from his horse, his foot entangled in a stirrup and dragged some distance before relieved. In this accident he received such a contusion of the brain as ever after seriously to affect his character and in some respects his conduct. In fact, his brother always considered Sidney a little deranged in his mind by that accident. His mental powers did not seem to be impaired, but the equilibrium in his intellectual exertions seemed thereby to have been sadly affected. He still manifested great mental activity and power, but he was to an equal degree inclined to run into wild and visionary views on almost every question. Hence he was a fit subject for any new movement in the religious world. -- A.H. Dunlevy, The Baptist Witness, March 1875 giving as his authority Dr. L. Rigdon, Sidney's brother.

    While this chapter barely touches the surface of the Rigdon theory, it is almost impossible not to see that the entire Mormon religion could well be based on fraud and deception. While the opposition for this theory may assert that if we were to produce a copy of Spaulding's manuscript they would believe, we can also assert that if they would produce the golden plates inscribed by the hand of God, we too would believe. It is remarkable, however, that such a thing should touch the church at Peters Creek, and a testimony of the faithfulness of God and of the church that it did not do more to consume and divide them than it did. Today, we stand thankful that it did not.

    (remainder of text not transcribed due to copyright restrictions)

    History of
    Washington County, PA

    by Boyd Crumrine
    (Philadelphia: L. H. Everts, 1882)

  • Washington Borough (excerpts)
  •         Washington Borough (full text)
  • Washington First Baptist Church
  • North Ten-mile Baptist Church
  • Peters Creek (excerpts)
            Rev. David Phillips
            Peters Creek Bap. Church.

  • [ 476 ]

    Chapter One


    The original owners of the site occupied by the borough of Washington were Abraham Hunter, Martha Hunter, and Joseph Hunter, Jr., who were among the host of applicants who thronged the land-office of the proprietaries immediately after its opening in the spring of 1769 for the sale of the lands which had been ceded by the Indians a few months previously by the treaty of Fort Stanwix....

    (text through p. 481 not yet transcribed)

    [ 482 ]

    James Wilson came from Burnt Cabin, Bedford Co., Pa., in 1781 andpurchased lot 291 where Smith's store now is. On it he erected a log house and on the 3rd of October at the first term of court in Washington County, Penna, he was licensed to keep a tavern. Later he bought lot 21, (where Charlton's confectionary now is), on the east side of Main Street. This lot was purchased on a certificate. In 1792 he passed his title to his son Hugh. A deed had previously been made to Hugh (Aug. 15, 1786). A house was built on this lot which at that time was the largest in the town and in it the shows that visited the place and various amateur performances were held. Dr. J. Julius Le Moyne first opened his drug store in this house. After his removal, Mrs Baker's Female Seminary was located here until her removal, in 1815, to a house on Maiden Street. James Wilson lived in the house he built on the corner of Main and Beau Streets until his death and his widow lived there several years after. He died in 1792 and by his will left to his wife, Margaret, the use of two hundred acres of land adjoining the town until James, the youngest son, should be of age; then the farm was to be divided equally between James, Thomas and John. Hugh, the oldest son, had been previously provided for by property set off to him among which was the lot on Main Street near Maiden Street. The house and lot where James Wilson Sr. lived and died was left to his youngest son, James, but it later came into possession of Hugh Wilson by whom it was owned many years. A daughter (Matty) of James Wilson became Mrs. Bryson. James, the younger son, was a coppersmith, and lived in the town several years. Of the other sons, except Hugh, nothing is known.

    [ 483 ]

    Hugh Wilson, in addition to the property obtained from his father purchased from James Marshel, in 1786, the lot on which now stands Morgan & Hargreaves' store. He opened a store on lot 21 before 1795 and was a merchant for many years. He married for his first wife, Rachel Leet, daughter of Isaac Leet and sister of Maj. Daniel Leet, by whom he had five children -- Rebecca, Margaret, Rachel, Hugh W., and Eliza.

    Rebecca Wilson became the wife of James Blaine who in 1809 opened a dry goods store next door to Hugh Wilson. Later he purchased the stone house built by David Bradford. In this house they both lived and died leaving no children. He was elected justice of the peace in 1817 and served three terms. He was also county treasurer from 1815 to 1817. Margaret, the second daughter of Hugh Wilson, became the wife of John Marshel, the son of Col. James Marshel. He was sheriff of the county in 1835 and before the expiration of the term was appointed cashier of the Franklin Bank (now First National). This position he retained until 1857 when he resigned and returned to a farm near Washington where he died. Mrs. Dr. Matthew H. Clark of Washington, and Mrs. S. A. Clark of Pittsburgh are his daughters. Rachel, the third daughter of Hugh and Rachel Wilson, became the wife of Richard Harding, and settled first in Alabama and later at Wheeling. Mrs. Harding now resides at Philadelphia with her daughter, Mrs. Rebecca Harding Davis, well known to the public as an authoress. Mrs. John L. Gow of Washington is also a daughter to Mrs. Harding.

    Hugh W. Wilson, the only son of Hugh and Rachel, settled in South Strabane, on the farm his grandfather purchased, and where his father built the residence in which James W. Wilson, the son of Hugh Wilson, now lives.

    Hugh Wilson, after the death of his first wife, married Margaret Fleming, a widow with one daughter who afterwards became the wife of the Rev. John McFadden of Pittsburgh. By the second wife he had one daughter, Eliza, who became the wife of the Rev. Thomas Swain of Philadelphia who was pastor of the Baptist Church at Washington, Penna, from 1846 to 1850. After his resignation as pastor of that church, they returned to Philadelphia. After the death of Margaret, the second wife, Hugh Wilson married a Miss Spencer, an English lady who survived him several years....

    (text through p. 492 not yet transcribed)

    [ 493 ]

    Early Taverns. -- The tavern kept by William Huston in 1774 was located just beyond the limits of the town on property now owned by Mrs. Swartz. A part of the old Huston farm is now embraced in the present limits of the borough. The first person to keep a public-house within the limits of Washington was then defined was James Wilson. He purchased a lot of David Hoge on the northwest corner of Beau and Main Streets, and at the first term of court in Washington County, held in October, 1781, he was licensed "for keeping a public-house of entertainment at Catfish Camp." He erected a log house, in which he opened his tavern, which he kept until his death in 1792. At this house the Hon. William A. Atlee and the Hon. George Bryan, judges of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, were in the habit of stopping when holding Courts of Oyer and Terminer in Washington County. The house was kept as a tavern as late as 1840, and in later years was weatherboarded. It was finally torn down, and Smith's store was erected upon its site. The property was owned many years by Hugh Wilson, son of James.

    John Dodd was one of the original proprietors of land adjoining the town of Washington. Very soon after the town was laid out he purchased lot 274, on the east side of Main Street, and in 1782 was licensed

    [ 494 ]

    to keep a tavern. He built a log house on the site now occupied by Hastings' hardware-store and the Washington Savings-Bank. In this house he kept tavern till his death in 1795, which occurred when returning from New Orleans. The deed for this lot bears date July 27, 1786, but this with lot No. 58 were purchased on a certificate, as was the case in the early lots. Judge J. C. Chambers, of this county, is a descendant of John Dodd.

    Charles Dodd, a brother of John Dodd, was licensed to keep a tavern in April, 1782. He kept a log house which stood on lot No. 58, now occupied by Strean's hardware-store. At this place the first courts were held, and in a log stable in the rear the prisoners of the county were confined. The deed of the lot was made to John Dodd May 30, 1789. On the 13th of August, 1792, John Dodd sold the house and lot to Daniel Kehr, who kept tavern a year or two, but later followed his trade of a shoemaker in the same house many years. His son, Isaac Kehr (afterwards spelled Kerr), succeeded to the property and lived there till his death.

    At the September term of court (1783) John Adams was licensed and kept tavern till 1789. John Colwell was licensed in 1784. At the September term in 1785, Hugh Means, Samuel Acklin, and William Falconer were licensed. Acklin kept ill 1788, and Falconer till 1791. William Meetkirke, who was for many years a justice of the peace, kept tavern where Mrs. McFarland now lives from June, 1786, to 1793.

    Maj. George McCormick, who purchased large tracts of land in the northern part of the county, was licensed to keep tavern in Washington in 1788. The following quotation from Col. John May's journal (page 99) refers to his house: "Thursday, Aug. 7, 1788, set out from the hotel at four o'clock, and at half-past eight arrived at Maj. George McCormick's in Washington, where we breakfasted. This is an excellent house, where our New England men put up."

    Hugh Wilson (son of James) was licensed in September, 1789; John McMichael and John Purviance in 1790. The latter owned lot No. 278, where the Fulton House now stands. He kept tavern as late as 1808, but resided here till the summer of 1817, when he removed to Claysville and laid out the town in that year.

    Charles Valentine purchased the lot on which the Valentine House now stands, and built upon it a log house, which he opened as a tavern upon receiving his license at the September term of court, 1791. This house, name "The White Goose," he kept till 1805, when he went into other business and died in 1809. It was kept by John Retteg from 1806 to 1810, and opened as "The Golden Swan." Juliana Valentine kept it from 1810 to 1819. In June, 1819, John Valentine advertised that he had just opened the house at the sign of "The Golden Swan." Later it was kept by Lewis Valentine, and in March, 1825, John Hays opened it. In March, 1827, it was kept by Isaac Sumny, with the sign of "Washington Hall." Its changes have been numerous, but it is the oldest tavern in the town. It is now known as the Valentine House, and is kept by William F. Dickey.

    Michael Kuntz was licensed in September, 1791, and kept one year where Vowell's drug-store now stands. J. Neilson, John Fisher, Samuel McMillan, and John Ferguson were each licensed December, 1798; Daniel Kehr in 1795.

    Joseph Huston, a cousin of William Huston, was licensed January, 1796, and opened a tavern in the stone house on the east side of Main Street below Maiden, at the sign of "The Buck." He kept there till 1812, and his widow Elizabeth succeeded him. She kept a short time there, rented the property to James Sargeant, who continued till April, 1815, when she again became the hostess, and kept it till after 1820.

    James Workman was licensed in 1797. He opened a house of entertainment, which he kept till 1813, when he retired to a farm out of town. In April, 1816, he advertised that he had opened a public-house at the sign of "General Andrew Jackson," on the west side of Main Street, just below the sign of "The Globe."

    Samul Thomas was licensed to keep tavern in September, 1797. He had purchased Lot No. 18, and in this year opened a tavern upon it. After a year he rented it to David Morris, who soon after purchased it, receiving his deed in 1804. From the time he took possession of the property till his death in 1834 the house was known as the "Globe" inn.

    The lot No. 18 was first sold by David Hoge to Alexander Cunningham in May, 1784, who conveyed it to Samuel Shannon the 30th of August the same year. On the 25th of May, 1804, Shannon conveyed to David Morris all his right, title, and interest. The deed has not passed in all these years, and on the 2d of June in that year a deed was made from Mr. Hoge to David Morris. He was licensed first in 1798, and opened the "Globe" tavern, where John Allen now lives, on Main Street. After the house came into his possession it was enlarged and improved, and became known as one of the best hotels between Washington, D. C., and Wheeling. This famous hotel was kept by David Morris till his death, Jan. 1, 1854. It was then continued by his widow a short time, and the property was sold to Thomas Morgan, who kept the post-office there the latter part of his term. An account of the many famous dinners served in the "Globe Inn" would be tedious. The last incident of any moment in connection with the old tavern occurred in 1833. On the 16th of April in that year Lieut. T. W. Alexander, of the United States army, having in charge as prisoners of war the renowned Black Hawk and five other Indians of the Sac and Fox tribes, arrived in this place by one of the stages on the old National road, being on their way to the

    [ 495 ]

    seat of government. They were all head men of their tribes, who were taken prisoners by Gen. Atkinson during the war of the summer previous. The names of the Indians were Ma-ka-tai-mesh-she-ka-kai, or Black Hawk; We-pe-kie-shich, or the Prophet; Nai-po-pe, or Broth; Mesh-she-was-kuck, son of Black Hawk; Pa-me-ho-its, brother of the Prophet; Pa-we-shich, son of the Prophet.

    An accident occurred to the stage in coming down Market Street, in which Sergeant Greene, one of the party, had his arm broken above the elbow, and Black Hawk, his son, and the son of the Prophet were slightly hurt. The accident caused a delay of several days, and gave "our citizens an opportunity of gratifying their curiosity with a sight of these celebrated wild sons of the forest, who had so recently caused such terror and distress to a portion of our pioneer settlers in the Far West."

    In October, 1797, John Scott opened a tavern (which was formerly occupied by John Fisher) at the sign of the "Spread Eagle." It was opposite David Acheson's store.

    In February, 1801, William McCammant opened a tavern at the sign of the "Cross Keys," on the southeast corner of Main and Wheeling Streets, opposite the "White Goose" (now the Valentine House). He remained as landlord until his death, in 1813. His widow, Mrs. Mary McCammant, continued till April, 1815, when she rented the property and moved to the southeast corner of Market and Beau Street, nearly opposite the court-house, where she opened a public-house at the sign of "General Washington." She was at the old place at the sign of the "Cross Keys" as late as January, 1831, and advertised for that term of court the following prices: dinner and horse-feed, twenty-five cents; jurors and others attending court, two dollars per week.

    Christian Kieffer kept tavern in February, 1805, at the sign of "Washington." John Rettig was licensed in 1806, and kept the stand formerly known as the "White Goose," at the corner of Market and Wheeling Streets, under the name of "The Golden Swan." Later he kept tavern in another part of the town, and was killed by falling down a well. His widow, Elizabeth Rettig, succeeded him in the business.

    Matthew Ocheltree was licensed in February, 1807, and opened tavern at the old stand formerly kept by James Wilson, and where Smith's store now stands. He remained at this place till about 1812.

    John McCluney in November, 1808, advertised that he had just opened a travelers' hotel opposite the court-house, at the sign of the "Indian Queen," where he kept for several years. In 1815 he opened a public-house formerly kept by Thomas Officer at the sign of the "Green Tree," at the north end of Market Street. Thomas Officer opened the "Green Tree" tavern in July, 1809. The house is yet standing.

    John Kline in April, 1815, moved from the Cross-Roads, nine miles west of Brownsville, and opened a public-house (formerly kept by Michael Ocheltree) at the sign of "General Wayne."

    James Garrett, in September, 1816, opened a public-house at the sign of the "Rising Sun," near the corner of Market and Chestnut Streets, where John and Andrew Best now reside. It was kept by Garrett till 1822, when James Briceland, from Briceland Cross-Roads, rented it and kept one year, when Garrett again took possession, and Briceland removed to "the Public-House and Stage-Office lately kept by Samuel Denniston." On the 1st of December, 1824, Gen. Andrew Jackson, family, and suite came to Washington and stopped at Briceland Inn. Several of the citizens of the town breakfasted with him, after which they escorted him as far as Hillsborough.

    Richard Donaldson opened a public-house in the year 1805 on the southeast corner of Market and Beau Streets, where the "Fulton House" now stands, where he kept till 1815, when he moved to the old Workman stand opposite the seminary, and now occupied by Mrs. Sarah Hanna. This house had been kept prior to this time by _____ Surratt. In April, 1823, Richard Donaldson moved to the brick house at the east end of Maiden Street, at the sign of "Commodore Perry."

    Dr. John Julius Le Moyne was licensed in August, 1798. He opened a tavern in his own house and kept till 1806.

    James Sargeant soon after the death of Joseph Huston in 1812 rented the tavern known as "The Buck," and kept it till 1815, when he removed to the corner of Main and Wheeling Streets, at the sign of the "Cross-Keys," where he kept till 1818. The next year he opened a hotel where the Fulton House now stands. David Wilson opened a house of entertainment in 1802, and continued till 1818. William Wilson kept a tavern on Wheeling Street from 1801 to 1808.

    John Fleming in April, 1820, opened a public-house opposite the market-house, "lately occupied by James Sergeant." The house was then known as the "Philadelphia and Kentucky Inn." During the month of January, 1821, on the occasion of the wedding of the daughter of Mr. Fleming, the house caught fire and was partially destroyed. A daughter, Mary, six years of age, was burned to death.

    Samuel Denniston in May, 1821, informed the public that he had removed from Greensburg, Westmoreland Co., to Washington, Pa., and commenced keeping public-house in the new and eligible brick house at the corner of Main and Maiden Streets, opposite where the United States turnpike road enters Main Street from the east, at the sign of the "Travelers' Inn and stage office." In 1823, James Briceland was the proprietor, and in 1825 James Dunlap kept it with the sign of "Jackson Hotel." This was the present Auld House.

    In 1822, John N. Dagg opened "The Rising Sun,"

    [ 496 ]

    formerly kept by James Garrett and James Briceland. On the 7th of April, 1827, he moved to the "Eagle Inn," opposite the Rising Sun, on Main Street, and later to what is now the Valentine House, after which he kept the Mansion House for several years. In 1836 John Irons opened it and occupied for a year or two, when Dagg again took possession and kept it many years.

    In April, 1821, Enoch Miller opened a hotel in the west end of the borough, in a large brick house nearly opposite the (old) Methodist meeting-house, on the National road, at the sign of "General Brown." Soon after, he opened the "Fountain Inn," which was in a brick house on Chestnut Street. He was succeeded in March, 1823, by George Ringland, who kept it a year or two.

    John Wilson, first licensed to keep a tavern Sept. 1, 1806, and kept till 1812. On the 7th of May, 1831, John Wilson opened a tavern opposite the court-house, called "John Wilson's Tavern." This was on the site of the old John Dodd tavern, and the present site of Hastings' hardware-store. Mr. Wilson kept there many years.

    (text through p. 509 not yet transcribed)

    [ 510 ]

    The First Presbyterian Church. -- Previous to the organization of the Presbyterian Church at Washington, Pa., 1793, the Presbyterians of the town and vicinity worshiped mainly with the church of Chartiers, near Canonsburg, which from 1775 until 1830 was under the pastoral care of the Rev. John McMillan, D. D., the first pastor west of the Alleghenies. The first notice of preaching in the town, found in the minutes of the old Presbytery of Redstone -- itself also formed in 1781, and now known as the mother of Western churches and presbyteries, -- is the application, Dec. 20, 1785, for the stated labors of Alexander Addison, then a licentiate of the Presbytery of Aberlow, Scotland, but afterwards a distinguished attorney, and the no less distinguished president judge of the district composed of the western counties of Pennsylvania, under the Constitution of 1790. The Presbytery of Ohio, embracing Washington, was organized out of a portion of Redstone in 1793, and in April following, “the congregation of Washington having represented to Presbytery that they had entered into an agreement with Mr. James Welsh, a licentiate under the care of the Presbytery of Transylvania, as stated supply for some time, the Presbytery heartily concurred therewith." Mr. Welsh continued his services for about a year, after which, as before, only occasional preaching was enjoyed from members of Presbytery and from traveling ministers. The names of the Rev. Messrs. Dodd, Mercer, Anderson, and Potter have come down in this connection, besides that of the Rev. Thomas Leslie Birch, who was the occasion of strife and alienation....

    The Rev. Matthew Brown, D. D., so well known afterwards as a distinguished minister and educator, was installed as the first pastor (of the Washington First Presbyterian Church) Oct. 16, 1805. He was a son of Dickinson College, and for several years had been pastor of the church of Mifflin, Pa. He was simultaneously called to be the principal of the Washington Academy. In the following year, 1806, he was a chief agent in procuring by special charter, the transformation of the academy into Washington College, and thereafter for ten years served with distinguished success as its first president. He continued as pastor of the church six years longer, until Sept. 25, 1812, when he accepted the presidency of Jefferson College at Canonsburg.

    One of the first movements of this energetic pastor was the effort to secure a permanent house of worship. The building was begun in the autumn of 1805 upon two lots in the southwestern part of the town, one of which was purchased from William Sherrard for five pounds, and the other from Andrew Swearingen, executor of the estate of Van Swearingen, for twenty dollars, the titles being made to Joseph Wherry, John Simonson, Parker Campbell, Hugh Wilson, and Daniel Moore, as trustees. The last two named gentlemen were Baptists in their convictions, but acted with the Presbyterian Church until the time came for the establishment of one of their own....

    (text through p. 516 not yet transcribed)

    [ 517 ]

    The First Baptist Church -- The minutes of this church show that it was regularly constituted on Friday, Oct. 14, 1814. In response to letters missive the following churches were represented by their delegates: Ten-Mile, Rev. Matthias Luce; Peters Creek, Rev. David Phillips, Deacon Joseph Phillips, Charles Daily; Union Town, Rev. William Brownfield. The right hand of fellowship was given by Rev. David Phillips on October 15th.

    "It was unanimously voted by the church that our brother, Charles Wheeler, be this day set apart by ordination to the work of the gospel ministry and to the performing of the ordinances of the gospel. Accordingly, after Brother Wheeler had given a satisfactory account of his views of the doctrine of the Scriptures, etc., he was ordained in the presence of this church and full assembly met, and received the imposition of hands by Elders D. Phillips, M. Luce, and W. Brownfield. This church held its first communion at the Lord’s Table on the Lord’s day following, viz., Oct. 16, 1814."

    The persons named below were the constituent members, seven of whom belonged to the Ten-Mile Church, viz.: Rebecca Dye, Rachel Wilson, Enoch Dye, Jr., Mary Dye, Jane Dye, Rebecca Blaine, Margaret Moore, Charles Wheeler, Charity A. Wheeler, Rachel Colloway, and Phillis Waller. A covenant and constitution was drawn up, signed by the constituent members, and is followed by the names of the members of the church to the year 1830, numbering one hundred and twenty-three persons.

    On the 29th of May, 1815, Hugh Wilson, Daniel Moore, and David Shields were elected trustees for one year, and requested to procure a lot of ground whereon to build a house for public worship. Aug. 26, 1815, the church voted to request admission to the Redstone Association. This request was granted by that body Sept. 2, 1815. At a church meeting May 11, 1816, Hugh Wilson reported: “That they had procured a Lott of ground on Wheeling Street, No. Seventy-Seven, which had been granted by John Hoge, Esq., (June 20, 1805) to James Gilmore, Robert Anderson and Alexander Little, Esqs., as Trustees for the purpose of Building Thereon a School-house and place of public worship, Said James Gilmore and Robert Anderson, Esqs., Conveyed said Lot of ground to Hugh Wilson, Daniel Moore and David Shields Trustees for the first Baptist Church and their successors in office for ever, for the purpose aforesaid." Title to the lot was confirmed by act of Legislature March 25, 1877.

    A notice was published in the Reporter of November, 1817, calling upon the members of the Baptist Church "to meet at the brick school-house to consider about building a house of worship." The brick school-house mentioned was in the rear of the lot they had purchased. The meeting was held Nov. 19, 1817, when a subscription paper was opened and a committee appointed to solicit subscriptions. Their efforts were successful, and a building committee was appointed. On the 11th of July, 1818, James Ruple was added to the “Building Committee to build the Meeting-House." The brick church edifice then built is the one still occupied. A meeting of the church was held Saturday, July 3, 1819, and the following quotation from the minutes shows the time when the church was first occupied: "Agreed to hold our communion to-morrow (it being a day appointed by the Association for a similar meeting being held at that place), and to meet in our new Meeting-House for the first time." The first election of deacons took place Dec. 9, 1820, when R. B. Chaplin and Daniel Dye were elected. The Association met here with this church in the summer of 1822. At a meeting of the church on Saturday, Oct. 9, 1824, after an address from their pastor, the Rev. Charles Wheeler, “It was resolved that Brother Wheeler be requested to furnish the church with a copy of his address, and that it be published and distributed to the churches of the Redstone Association. Resolved that this church does not consider itself bound by the Philadelphia Confession of Faith, nor any other human confession, but by the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament, as their only guide of faith and practice." At a meeting Jan. 8, 1825, request was made by the Union congregation, afterwards the Associate Reformed (now the United Presbyterian), for the use of their church one-half of the time till they could build a church. After due consideration it was thought not advisable to continue the evening service through the winter, and they decided not to grant the request, but extended to them the privilege of its use for preaching or communion when it was not occupied by them. At this time, Sept. 11, 1825, a request was made for the services of Mr. Wheeler one Sabbath of the month for the Ten-Mile Church. This request was granted, and he was to commence the first Sabbath of November. In January, 1826, the church discussed the question whether it would be advisable to hold connection longer with the Redstone Association. Rev. Charles Wheeler, H. Wilson, Samuel Marshal, James Ruple, and R. B. Chaplin were appointed messengers to the Association in July of 1826.

    The Association convened and refused to accept letters from all churches that did not mention the Philadelphia Confession of Faith as embodying their faith. This action brought about the rejection of fourteen churches, leaving but twelve to form the Association. The Washington Church was one of the fourteen, and non-fellowship was declared with it. The rejected messengers met at a house near by, and resolved to meet at Washington the Saturday before the second Sunday in November, and then to

    [ 518 ]

    sit in council, and if agreeable to the majority form a new Association. Also that Brethren Matthias Luce, Charles Wheeler, and Ephraim Eslip [sic - Estep?] be a committee to meet at Peters Creek Church and draft rules and regulations for the government of the new Association. Delegates from the following churches met as agreed, Nov. 11, 1826: Peters Creek, Maple Creek, Somerset, Connellsville, Big Redstone, Pigeon Creek, Ten-Mile, Bates' Fork, Ruff's Creek, Wheeling Creek, Cross Creek, Harmon's Creek, Brush Run, and Washington. Matthias Luce was moderator. The articles of the Association were read by one of the committee and adopted. There were copies sent to all churches. It was resolved that the Association should meet at Washington in September of 1827. Entire harmony prevailed, and May 12, 1827, the articles of the Washington Baptist Association were read and adopted by the church.

    The Rev. Charles Wheeler, who was ordained Oct. 15, 1814, remained pastor of the church from that time until 1839. For several years the church was supplied with pastors whose calls were only temporary. There was a call to the Rev. [B.] Davis, who occupied the pulpit for four months. In January, 1841, there were given calls to the Revs. Bell and Collins. A call to the Rev. [A. K.] Bell, to serve the church until a settled pastor could be secured, was given April 3, 1841. A protracted meeting, at which it was decided to form a Sunday-school, was held, conducted by the Revs. Bell and Collins. The Rev. ____ Collins was educated at Hamilton College, New York. He remained pastor until April 12th. During his pastorate one hundred and four were added to the church. The Revs. Charles F. Johnson, Billings, and Anderson each served a short time. The Rev. Charles T. Johnson served in the year 1842-43. B. W. Tisdale, who became pastor Sept. 9, 1843, held his position until Feb. 13, 1846, when he resigned, his resignation to take effect April 1, 1846. On the 20th of September, 1846, a call to the pastoral charge of this church was extended to the Rev. Thomas Swain, of New Jersey. He accepted the call, and assumed charge the first Sabbath in October of that year. He was ordained Nov. 10, 1846. At this ordination delegates were present from the churches of Peters Creek, Grant Street Church of Pittsburgh, Hollidaysburg Church, and Spruce Street Church, Philadelphia. The charge was given to the candidate by Rev. James Eslip. He resigned his position Sept. 8, 1850. A call given to the Rev. George Young, Oct. 28, 1850, was accepted, and his position assumed Dec. 19, 1850; also a resignation, Nov. 12, 1854. The church was repaired in April, 1856. It was also received into the Pittsburgh Association, June, 1858. Daniel Moore had purchased a lot of ground for a parsonage Jan. 12, 1850. It was resolved to erect a parsonage as soon as the fund could be raised. Thomas Swain, H. W. Wilson, and James Ruple were the committee for that purpose. The Rev. Malachi Taylor became a chosen pastor in October, 1855. He assumed his duties Dec. 1, 1856, and resigned July, 1857, his resignation to take effect Sept. 1, 1857. A call to Rev. John Boyd was tendered April, 1858, and in June he took charge. A resignation from him was received Dec. 2, 1859. In 1865, Rev. [H.] Adams served for three months. R. Talford was called Jan. 31, 1866. He accepted in February, but resigned June 10, 1868. The resignation was not accepted until June 28th. J. A. Snodgrass supplied the pulpit from Oct. 29, 1871, until 1875. July 25, 1875, a call was sent to the Rev. Malcom C. Blaine. It was accepted, and he took charge August 8th. His resignation was made Sept. 15, 1878, to take effect October 1st. A call to the Rev. J. C. Tuttle was given April 27, 1879; he accepted and assumed the position July 1, 1879. His resignation was received July 9, 1882, which leaves the church at present without a pastor.

    Following is an imperfect list of officers of this church, viz.: Trustees, Hugh Wilson, Daniel Moore, and David Shields, May 29, 1815; James Ruple, March 9, 1833; H. W. Wilson, Jan. 12, 1850; J. L. Dye, May 29, 1861; J. L. Dye, April 1, 1865; James Wilson, Henry Hull.

    Clerks, Enoch Dye, March 1, 1815; Hugh Wilson, May 29, 1815; James Ruple, May 10, 1828; Henry Hull, Dec. 2, 1855 (still clerk).

    Deacons, R. B. Chaplin and Daniel Dye, Dec. 9, 1820; Daniel Moore, July 9, 1829; Hugh Wilson (vice R. B. Chaplin, resigned), March 12, 1831; Henry Ritner (vice Wilson, deceased), May 9, 1836; Daniel Dye, May, 1842; James B. Riggs, ____ Little, November, 1851; ____ Jennings, ____ McDonough, Aug. 22, 1860; Samuel Kelley, Jan. 11, 1868; ____ Bane, G. G. Holmes, Feb. 17, 1872; W. L. McCleary, Jan. 13, 1877.

    The church has at present fifty-nine members. The present trustees are W. H. Wilson, John L. Dye, and Henry Hull.

    For a more extended history of the early Baptist Church in this county reference is made to the history of the Ten-Mile Baptist Church in Amwell township, which contains the first minutes of Redstone Association, constituted in 1776.

    [ 669 ]

    North Ten-Mile Baptist Church. -- The families of the Banes and others settled on the waters of Ten-Mile Creek in 1768 were Baptists from Virginia and descendants of such. The families of Sutton and others settled a little later in what is now Fayette County. Several of the Suttons were Baptist ministers, and a church called Great Bethel was organized by them at what is now Uniontown in 1770. Two years later (1772) a church was constituted in the Bane settlement, in Amwell township, at the house of Enoch Enochs, where Charles Rossel now lives. The minutes of the early years are still in existence, and from them are taken the quotations given below. The record of the first meeting is illegible and cannot be made out. It proceeds:

    "December 1st, 1773. The church met on business the first time at Enoch Enochs', and after Solemn Prayer Proceeded. Made choice of Samuel Parkhurst, Clerk.

    "Feb'y 4th, 1774. The church met on business at Brother David Enochs', and after Solemn Prayer Proceeded: 1st, chose Brother Issachar Huntington Deacon; 2d, chose Alexander Keith to supply the place of a Clerk to Raise the Psalm Tune; 3d, chose Brother James Sutton, and Received him as our Minister; 4th, appointed the Friday before the first Sabbath in the next March to be a meeting of church business, and the Saturday following to be a day of Fasting, the Sabbath to be a Communion with us.

    "Before our next appointed Communion the Church being scattered on Account of the Indians, so that we could not attend in any Church order until the next fall, Brother Sutton moved over the mountains, and Returned to us the next October.

    "November 31st, 1774. The Church met at Joseph Bane's to Consult the welfare of Zion, and after Solemn Prayer conclude to appoint the last Lord's day in next April to attend the Communion of the Supper at Enoch Enoch's, The Saturday before preparatory."

    The record shows that on the 13th of October 1775, Robert Bennet was received by letter, also John Buckingham on the 16th of February 1776, and Cheniah Covalt and Cimfer A. Bennet on the 15th of February, 1777. The next entry found is as follows:

    "At our meeting June 16, 1781, gave our Ministering Brother, John Corbley, an invitation to attend with us statedly in the administration of the word and the ordinances of the Gospel.

    "About the first of May, 1783, our ministering Brother, David Sutton made us a visit from the Jerseys, and the church gave him an invitation to come and settle amongst us which he accepted, and the next fall he moved out here with his family. (Mr. Sutton remained as pastor till his death in 1812. At that time he resided in West Bethlehem.)

    "March 18, 1786. At our meeting of Business agreed that the meeting-house be finished by a levi on each Ratable Estate, Brother John Buckingham and David Enoch to have the oversight thereof."

    The first meeting-house was built in 1786. It was of logs, and was used until 1794. On the 10th of May in that year Samuel Parkhurst, a trustee of the society, purchased twenty-one acres and twenty perches of land for £2 5s. of Daniel McFarland. It was situated on the waters of Ten-Mile, on the tract of land called in the survey "Big Rocks." On this land the society built a hewed log house, which was occupied many years. The society about 1840 built the present brick meeting-house, and on the 1st of July, 1842, Philip Axtell, John Bane, Lewis Ketchum, acting deacons, purchased one acre and one hundred and thirty-one perches of land, in consideration of twelve and a half cents, of Jacob Bane. The deed bears date July 1, 1842, and says "on which now stands the new brick meeting-house." The land on which it stands was warranted to Nathan Bane in 1786, and is part of a tract of three hundred and four acres known as "Bane's Fancy."

    The pastors from the first, connected with the church as far as can be ascertained, have been as follows: James Sutton, Feb. 4, 1774-80; John Corbly, June 16, 1781-83; David Sutton, May 1, 1783, till his death in 1812. From this time till 1836, the records are lost, and nothing positive can be ascertained. In that year the Rev. A. B. Bowman became the pastor, and served until 1839, when he resigned, and Levi Griffith was called, accepted, and ministered to them till 1842, when F. Downey succeeded him, and served four years. His successors were William Whitehead, S. Kendall, _____ Lenning, T. C. Gunford, Winfield Scott, B. P. Ferguson, J. Boyd, W. B. Skinner, C. W. Tilton, and J. Miller, who is the present pastor.

    This church was the first one of any denomination organized in Washington County. It became in 1776 one of the constituent members of the Redstone Association. The minutes of that body for the early years were never published, and as they were found in this section it is thought proper in the history of this first church to give quotations from them. Several of the churches here mentioned are not now in existence, and little knowledge of them has been obtained:

    "Book A. -- Minutes of the Annual Association of the Baptist Churches west of the Laurel Hill, called the Redstone Association.

    "Met in Annual Association at Goshen, west of the Laurel Hill, Oct. 7, 1776, the following messengers from the several churches, viz.:

    "1. Great Bethel. * -- Isaac Sutton, James McCoy, and Elijah Barclay. 2. Goshen. -- John Corbly, John Gerrard, and Jacob VanMetre. 3. Ten-Mile. -- James Sutton, David Enoch, and Robert Bennett. 4. Turkey Foot. -- Isaac Morris. 5. Pike Run. -- William Wood and David Ruble. 6. Yough. -- Samuel Luallen and John McFarland.

    "1st The introductory sermon was preached by Mr. James Sutton from these words, "The Angel of the Church," Rev. ii. 1, wherein the duty of messenger was clearly exhibited. 2d. Proceeded to business. Brother John Corbly was chosen moderator, and William Wood clerk, 3d. … 4th. A request from Cross Creek for the constitution of a church granted, and Brothers John Corbly and William Wood appointed to officiate in constituting the said church. Query. In what state did Adam stand in Paradise, whether he partook of the Diving nature in his creation or not.

    "Answer. Adam was created in an upright State, but that he partook of the divine nature as the essence of God, we cannot suppose only that he received so much of the divine nature as was sufficient to actuate his righteous soul thereby."

    "Met in Annual Association at Great Bethel, Monongalia Co., Va. [now in Fayette County, Pa.], Oct. 13, 1777, the following members of Goshen; Turkey Foot, Richard Hall, Henry Abrams; Pike Run, William Wood, James Rogers, Morris Brundy; Forks of Cheat, Samuel Luallen; Yough; Ten-Mile; Simpson Creek, William Davis, Dana Edwards; Georges Creek, Joseph Barnet, Peter Jones; Cross Creek, William Taylor."

    "At a meeting of the Association on the 2d, 3d, and 4th of October, 1780 (place not given), the number of members in the different churches were given as follows: Great Bethel, 49; Ten-Mile, 9; Yough, 34;

    * 1. Great Bethel was at Uniontown, Fayette Co. 2. Goshen, in Greene County. 3. Ten-Mile, at Bane's, in Amwell township, Washington Co. 4. Turkey Foot, at Confluence, Somerset Co. 5. Pike Run, in Vaneville, Somerset township, Washington Co. 6. Yough, organized in 1773, afterwards became the Peters Creek Church, now at Library, Allegheny County.

    [ 670 ]

    Goshen, 30; Forks of Cheat, 19; Simpson's Creek, 19; Pigeon Creek, 45.

    "A request from separate church on Shirtee to join Association. Resolved, That William Woods, John Corbly, William Taylor, Isaac Light, David Phillips, and John Buckingham _____ Williams be appointed to attend at Benjamin Rennoes on Shirtee [now Allegheny County] the Wednesday after the fourth Sabbath in October, to examine into the state and order of that church, and if found satisfactory to receive them into fellowship with us."

    "Association of 1781 met on Saturday before the first Sabbath at Great Bethel. Nine churches represented. Patterson and Cross Creek received into fellowship."

    "On the 2d of October, 1784, the Association met at Muddy Creek. The following churches were represented. The names of the churches, messengers, and number of members are here given: Great Bethel, Rev. Isaac Sutton, James Sutton, Isaac Morris, Thomas McGloughlin, 120 members; Ten-Mile, Rev. David Sutton, Robert Bennet, Samuel Parker, Isaac Bane, 31 members; Peters Creek, Rev. William Taylor, 45 members; Goshen, Rev. John C orbley, Levi _____, James Meredick, Daniel Clark, 40 members; Forks of Cheat, John McFarland and others, 40 members; Pigeon Creek, Rev. William Wood, Z. Williams, David Ruble, William Buckingham, 35 members; Simpson Creek, Rev. Isaac Edwards, John Stohe, 32 members; Georges Hill, Moses Airs, William Carter, 95 members.

    "Association met on the 27th October, 1788. Twelve churches were represented. Rev. John Corbly was moderator, and Benjamin Jones clerk."

    September 24, 25, and 26, 1796, met at Uniontown, fifteen churches represented. Enon (Fallowfield township) represented by Henry Speers and John Raton.

    In 1806 the Association met at Cross Creek, Brooke Co., Va. Twenty-nine churches were represented. Sept. 22, 23, 1820, at Plum Run; Aug. 31, 1822, at Washington; Sept. 5,6,7, 1823, at Pittsburgh; Sept. 1,2,3, 1826, at Redstone.

    At the last session it was resolved that "the doctrines held by the Washington Church and their ministers are found to be heterodox... and they are hereby excluded from our fellowship." This was about the time when the church became divided by dissensions, resulting from the teachings of Thomas and Alexander Campbell.

    [ 891 ]

    The Rev. David Phillips was emphatically the leading clergyman of the pioneer days of Peters township. He was born in Wales in 1742, and emigrated from that country to America with his father's family, settling in Chester County, Pa. He married during his residence at that place, and in 1780 came into Washington County and took a warrant for land which now lies in both Allegheny and Washington Counties. This tract of land was surveyed to him as three hundred and ninety acres, under the title of "Norwich," and he obtained the patent for it March 4, 1786. In 1809 he sold one hundred and fourteen acres of this land to his son Isaac, and the land upon which the present house of worship of Peters Creek Baptist Society stand was granted by Mr. Phillips for the church site. Rev. Mr. Phillips was a member of the Great Valley Baptist Church before coming to this section, and had held a captain's commission in the Revolutionary War. He reared a large family of children, and when he died at the age of eighty-seven years, having given more than forty years of his life to the exclusive service in the cause of Christ, he left numerous descendants. Among them were Rev. T. C. Phillips of New York City; Joshua Phillips, of Pittsburgh, Pa.; J. M. Phillips, of Chattanooga, Tenn.; Byram Pratt, residing in the State of Pennsylvania; and Henry and Archibald Bass, both living in Tennessee. It is said that a full company of lineal descendants of Rev. David Phillips served in the Union army during the late Rebellion, and that at the present time the persons living who trace their lineage directly back to him number nearly one thousand. The old Phillips homestead is now occupied by Charles Phillips. (The preceding is mainly based on information received from Samuel King, of Allegheny County.)

    Enoch Philips came to Peters township, and on April 2, 1796, purchased one hundred and four acres of land of John Allison, a part of the tract patented by Anthony Dunleavy, under the title of "The Tower," this portion of which he sold to John Allison, May 17, 1792. Enoch Phillips continued to reside upon this land for a long time. He kept one of the taverns known here at an early day, it being located at the forks of the road near his farm. He was a soldier in the war of 1812. His son, David Phillips, also kept a house of public entertainment in 1826, occupying the same house his father did at an earlier date. His son, David Phillips, has a farm in this township, and there is still standing upon it a house built in 1814. David Phillips, Jr., was elected to the office of justice of the peace April 10, 1855, and served two terms.

    James Mitchell came from Ireland to this country, and served for a time in the Revolutionary war. On Oct. 15, 1791, having come into Peters township, he purchased a part of the tract of land called "Crookston'" of about three hundred acres. The tract was granted to Richard and Levi Crooks on a Virginia certificate, and patented May 1, 1786. James Mitchell made his home for life on the place, save a few years that he lived in Williamsport, now Monongahela City. Mr. Mitchell filled the office of justice of the peace for many years, and was one of the first elders in Peters Creek Church. He had one daughter, who became the wife of John Wright, of Monongahela City. Mr. and Mrs. Wright settled on the Mitchell homestead, and it is still in the possession of their descendants.

    Andrew Devore was one of the early settlers of Peters township, although no accurate dates of his investments have been found. He, however, owned a large tract of land, taking it up as one of the original settlers. A portions of the tract is now owned by James Johnston.

    Churches. -- Peters Creek Baptist Church was constituted Nov. 10, 1773, the covenant made and executed on that day being signed by the following persons, viz.:Rev. John Whittaker, minister; members, Thomas Applegate, J. Barrett, Henry Semmons, Peter Elrod, Christopher Miller, Mary Whittaker, Margaret Jaret, and Ailey Lemmons.

    The church thus formed used as a place for their religious services a log house which was built on the Robert Estep property, which is now in Union township, but then belonged to the territory of Peters township. The Rev. John Whittaker preached for them for some time after, but for what length of time is not known, as no church records are extant until the year 1793. From a road record filed in the recorder's office at Washington, in this county, it is seen that in 1783 this society presented a petition that a road might be opened "from McKee's Ferry to the Peters Creek Meeting-House."

    The trustees of Peters Creek Baptist Church purchased a building site of John Cox and wife, the transfer being made Sept., 10, 1788, according to the tenor of a deed recorded on page 462, Book 2, vol. i., of Washington County records. The church edifice was built on property now owned by Benjamin Lytle, adjoining the Bradford mill.

    Among the relics having reference to the early history of the church is an ancient subscription paper which is now in possession of E. M. Townsend, of Peters township, and of which the following is a copy:

    "We, the under-subscribers, do promise to pay or cause to be paid the sums annexed to our names, for the use of the Rev. David Phillips, for his labour in the gospel, into the hands of William Phillips, and that on or before the first day of March ensuing."Witness our hands this second day of May, 1789."
    				£	s.	d.
    William Phillips...............	2	0	0
    Lemuel Sayer...................	2	0	0
    Joseph Phillips................	1	0	0
    Samuel Foster..................	1	0	0
    John Masters...................		7	6
    Peter Sharp....................	1	4	0
    Richard Masters................	1	0	0
    Daniel Townsend................	2	0	0
    Peter Rowletter................	1	0	0
    Abram Whittaker................	1	0	0
    Thomas Rigdon..................	1	0	0
    William Rigdon.................	       12	0
    John Mallory...................		6	0

    [ 892 ]

    This paper shows that Rev. David Phillips was serving the church at that time. The church then consisted of two branches, one at Elizabethtown and one at Peters Creek. Rev. Mr. Phillips was called to the ministry of these two churches in April, 1781, and in the May following was ordained by a council consisting of Rev. Mr. Woods and William Taylor, and from that date preached at Elizabethtown, Finleyville, and Budd's Ferry, on the Youghiogheny River, until 1793. In the assessment-roll for Peters township in 1784 he is mentioned as "Preaching David Phillips," to distinguish him from Col. David Phillips, also a resident of the township.

    In 1793 there occurred a revival in the Peters Creek branch, through which the church was greatly augmented in numbers, and on Jan. 1, 1794, they chose Rev. Mr. Phillips for their pastor. The consolidation with the Elizabethtown branch soon followed, and the two were afterwards one society, and one pastor served both, there being two houses of worship in use, one at or near Gastonville, and one at Elizabethtown.

    On April 3, 1810, the property at Gastonville was sold by the pastor and Daniel Townsend and Charles Daily, trustees of said church, to James Gaston. Two years later Samuel Gaston became the owner of the land. The proceeds of the sale of the church property were applied to the erection of a hewed log house upon another building lot, which was the gift of the pastor, Rev. Mr. Phillips, and which was used until 1832, when it gave place to the present brick edifice. Rev. Mr. Phillips continued to discharge the duties of pastor of the Baptist Church until 1824, when he became disqualified by his great age. He died in 1829, of paralysis, leaving many relatives and friends, and loved and honored by all who knew him.

    From 1824 to 1829 the church was supplied by several ministers, among whom were Revs. Charles Wheeler, John Winter, and Joshua Bradley. During this time the quiet of the church was so greatly disturbed by the doctrines preached by Rev. Alexander Campbell and others of his faith that on Aug. 5, 1829, a meeting was held and the society adopted the Philadelphia Baptist Confession of Faith, in concurrence with its former church covenant and discipline, as generally expressive of its views of Scriptural doctrine.

    Early in the year 1829, Rev. William Shadrach, a young man who had just commenced to preach, was given a trial in the church, and so pleased the people that he was called to the pastorate of the church, which he accepted. This relation existed for six years (the new brick church being built at a cost of $1250, and the cemetery renovated and improved during the time), when it was dissolved at the pastor's request. Revs. William Penny and Benoni Allen seem to have served the church jointly for the next three years, and were then succeeded by Rev. James Estep, who was unanimously chosen pastor.

    This relation continued for nearly a score of years, when Dr. Estep became enfeebled by old age and was obliged to resign, although the occasionally filled the pulpit afterwards. He died Feb. 26, 1861, after having given more than half a century to the ministry.

    Rev. David Williams, who came to preach in the church in January, 1859, remained four years, and, under his teachings the church grew and prospered greatly. Of Rev. George Saymore's service here it has been said, "His pastorate took place during the great Rebellion, which moved the heart and tried the spirit, resources, and patriotism of every loyal citizen, and this church felt deeply the paralyzing influence on its prosperity and piety." The Rev. J. W. Collins commenced his labors with the people of Peters Creek Baptist Church in March, 1866, remained two years, and through his influence a number of new members were added to the church, and the building was repaired and improved. Rev. A. G. Collins succeeded him in 1869 and labored three years, when Rev. Henry Lewellen came to the place, and is still in charge, having served all the years in a most gratifying manner.

    Since the organization of the Baptist Church the persons who have served as its deacons have been Joseph Phillips, Sr., Joseph Higbee, Charles Daily, Ephraim Estep, Isaac King, William Benson, John King, Joseph Phillips, John Maits, Sr., John Maits, Jr., Samuel Hetts, Peter Boyer, Samuel Boyer, Edward Riggs, and Isaac Phillips. Between six hundred and seven hundred persons have been received on profession of faith, and the contributions of the church to the various evangelical societies have been very liberal in proportion to its ability. Of the many persons who have gone out from this church to engage in ministerial work, Charles and John Rigden labored in Ohio, James Estep and Henry Wade were two of whom but little has been learned, Joshua Phillips is now preaching in Ohio, and J. W. Higbee is in the University of Lewisburg as a licentiate. Sidney Rigden [sic] went from here and for some time was pastor of the First Baptist Church in Pittsburgh. He first became interested in the peculiar tenets advocated by Rev. Alexander Campbell, and afterwards made a total wreck of his faith and the hopes of his brethren by associating himself with Joseph Smith in originating and espousing Mormonism.

    For more than a hundred years this church has been enthusiastic and generous in the advancement of religion, and for upwards of forty years has ably and creditably sustained its excellent Sabbath-school. The church edifice has always belonged to the old original territory of Peters township, but at one time was in the part since set off as Union township, then in Peters township, and is now within the limits of Library, Allegheny County, but a little distance from the county line.

    (After Rigdon's First Baptism)

    1817 Aug Annual Meeting of the Redstone Association at Peter's Creek; both Sidney Rigdon and Alexander Campbell attended
    1817-18   SR said to have "coveted the aging David Philips's pastorship." and "began to put himself forward and seek the preeminence"
    1818 Jan 1 Partnership of Robert & Joseph Patterson suffered bankruptcy and was replaced by the Partnership of Robert Patterson & J. Harrison Lambdin; Lambdin had been a former employ of Robert Patterson in his previous partnership with Mr. Hopkins; the firm operated a book store on 4th St., a book bindary, and a separate job-office print shop under the name of Butler and Lambdin; Robert & Joseph Patterson appear to have begun or continued only one division of their former firm at this time: the Robert & Joseph Patterson steam paper mill on the Allegheny River
    1818 Wtr-Spr Alexander Campbell opened Buffalo Seminary, located near Brush Run in Washington Co.; Alexander lived on his father-in-law's farm (Brown Farm)
    1818   Obadiah Newcomb became Minister of First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh
    1818 Aug Annual Meeting of the Redstone Association (at Peter's Creek?) both Sidney Rigdon and Alexander Campbell attended; Campbell served as association secretary that year
    1818   SR moved to North Sewickley on the Connoquenessing River, where he studied for the ministry under the Reverend Andrew Clark, minister of the Providence Regular Baptist Church
    1818-19   Adamson Bentley met Alexander Campbell when his family was traveling across the mountains of Pennsylvania to their new home.
    1819 Feb. 27 SR Presented Dismission from the Peters Creek Church and accepted into the Providence Regular Baptist Church of North Sewickley
    1819 Sum Thomas Campbell moved to West Middleton, PA; assisted son Alexander at nearby Buffaloe Seminary in VA
    1819 Mar SR received preaching license from the Regular Baptists in PA
    1819   SR may have served as assistant to Rev. Obadiah Newcomb in Pittsburgh; kept membership in Providence Baptist Church
    1819 Aug 4 SR received letter of dismission from Providence Baptist Church
    1819 Fall Annual meeting of Beaver Association in New Lisbon, OH -- lists Sidney Rigdon as a member -- Andrew Clark, Adamson Bentley, and another minister were appointed to a committee which was to consider the ordination of Sidney Rigdon, provided the church applied for this ordination
    1819-20   SR occasionally returned briefly to Library area, may have engaged in occasional preaching at First Baptist Church in Pittsburgh and/or Peter's Creek Church
    1819-20?   Mrs. Nancy Rigdon left the farm and went to live with her daughter Lacy Rigdon Boyer (Mrs. Peter Boyer).

    1820   Rev. Andrew Clark ended his ministry at Providence Baptist Church
    1820   Rev. George Forrester drowned in the Allegheny River
    1820   Walter Scott becomes Forrester's replacement as Minister of "Sandemanian" or "Haldanean" church in Pittsburgh; also called the "New Light Presbyterian Society"
    1820   John Davis became Minister of First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh
    1820 Jan-Feb SR may have served as assistant to Rev. John Davis in Pittsburgh
    1820 Mar. 4 SR presented Aug. 4 letter to Warren Baptist Church
    1820 Mar-Apr? SR moved in with Adamson Bentley, an ordained Baptist minister in Warren, OH
    1820 Apr 1 SR requested a certificate as a licensed preacher -- licensed to preach by Concord Baptist Church of Warren (later called Warren Central Christian Church under Campbellites) -- served as traveling evangelist in the Warren region -- preached in northern Trumbull Co. (as did "Elder Goff")
    1820   SR met Phebe Brooks, of Bridgetown, Cumberland Co., NJ; she was the sister of Adamson Bentley's wife
    1820 bef. Aug 24 SR ordained a Baptist minister in Warren OH
    1820 Jun 12 SR married Phebe Brooks (prob. in Warren by Rev. A. Bentley)
    1820 Jun 19-20 Alexander Campbell debated with Seceder Presbyterian Minister John Walker in Mount Pleasant, OH
    1820 Sum Sidney Rigdon and Adamson Bentley baptized in Warren and vicinity "upward of ninety persons.
    1820 ? SR visited Pittsburgh region; preached four Sundays at First Baptist Church while visiting in Library area; may have been informally invited to apply for the Pastor's position there by some members (this may be the same trip as the one reported for Nov)
    1820 Aug 24-26 Last Annual Meeting of the Beaver Baptist Association in Connoquenessing; Rigdon reported to have already been ordained; Sidney was asked with his mentor Bentley and cousin Charles to draft the "Corresponding Letter" for the year.
    1820 Aug 30 The "middle division" of the old Beaver Association met at Salem, where Andrew Clark was now minister, and formed the Mahoning Association, covering the counties of Trumbull, Portage, Mahoning, and some of Columbiana County and consisting of the churches of Warren, New Lisbon, Nelson, Youngstown, Salem, Randolph, Liberty, Mount Hope, Bazetta, and Braceville.
    1820 Oct 4 Beaver Baptist Association was formally divided and the newly formed Mahoning Association (mostly in OH) would become the future seedbed for Alexander Campbell's views
    1820-21   Concord Baptist Church of Warren built its first meeting house; Rigdon assisted in the construction and "occasionally delivered a sermon from the church's pulpit"
    1820-21   Alexander Campbell occasionally visited the First Baptist Church in Pittsburgh and preached there, winning some members over to his reform
    1821   Alexander Campbell first met Walter Scott (suspect date)
    1821   Alexander Campbell's Debate with Walker published; read enthusiastically by Adamson Bentley and Sidney Rigdon
    1821 Jul While traveling through Virginia, Brothers Bentley and Rigdon visited Alexander Campbell at Buffaloe (the future Bethany, West Virginia) and after a day and a night's stay both men were won over to his reform cause.
    1821 Sum Rigdon and Bentley return to Warren, to spread Campbell's reforms among the Baptists of the Western Reserve.
    1821   Rev. John Davis left the First Baptist Church in Pittsburgh
    1821 Sept Sidney was a member in the council of the Mahoning Baptist Association, convening that year at Palmyra, Portage County, Ohio. At the meeting, he was asked to become the Association's messenger to the Grand River Association and to write the "Corresponding Letter" for the next year.
    1821 Nov SR took his family to visit his mother and sister in PA; conferred with First Baptist congregation in Pittsburgh and received an invitation to become their full-time to succeed Rev. John Davis as the 4th Pastor there -- the plan behind this invitation was initiated and pushed forward by Alexander Campbell, who in 1821 still had some influence in the Redstone Association, to which the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh belonged; Campbell also used his influence to get Rigdon to accept the offer.
    1821 Dec 2 Phebe Brooks Rigdon baptized into Concord Church at Warren
    1822 Jan 5 SR ended his ministry in the Warren region with final sermon at Warren -- Rigdon and Phebe his wife requested letters of dismission to the baptist Church at Pittsburgh which was granted
    1822 Jan 28 SR arrived in Pittsburgh to become Minister of the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh (under the jurisdiction of the Redstone Baptist Association)
    1822 Feb 6? SR officially became the Minister of the First Baptist Church
    1822   John Johnson resigned as Postmaster of Pittsburgh and was replaced by his son-in-law William Eichbaum; John's daughter, R. J. Eichbaum (also William's wife) worked in the Post Office when her husband was absent; she recalled knowing Robert & Joseph Patterson, Silas Engles, J. Harrison Lambdin and Sidney Rigdon during this general time-period
    1823 Jan 1 The firm of Patterson & Lambdin (along with their Butler & Lambdin Print Shop) in Pittsburgh went into banckruptcy. If a copy of the Spalding MS had survived in the Print Shop until this date it was probably then disposed of along with the other possessions of the bankrupt firm.
    1823   Alexander Campbell begins publishing the "Christian Baptist"
    1823 Spr? Rev. John Winter later claimed that at this time he saw "a large manuscript" which was "a romance of the Bible" in Sidney Rigdon's study; Winter also claimed that Rigdon told him the MS had been written by "a Presbyterian Minister, Spaulding, whose health had failed, brought this to the printer to see if it would pay to publish it; Winter's daughter, Mary W. Irvine, later said that her father was informed that Rigdon "had gotten it from the printers to read it as a curiousity."
    1823 Spr SR worked as an advocate of Alexander Campbell's reforms while serving as Minister the First Baptist Church in Pittsburgh
    1823 Spr SR refused to teach the "Philadelphia Confession of Faith" in Pittsburgh; argued against infant damnation with Pittsburgh school teacher and Baptist Minister John Winter; following this Winter soon "formed an opposition coalition of twelve to twenty members" within Rigdon's congregation
    1823 Jun 28 SR sold his inherited land near Library to James Means
    1823 Jul 11 Winter's group excluded Rigdon and denied him the "liberty of speaking in self defense;" the Rigdon group of "seventy to eighty members and the smaller Winter group each claimed to be the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh;" declaring "non-fellowship" and expelling each other.
    1823 Aug Threatened with expulsion of his Brush Run Church from the Redstone Association, Alexander Campbell and the newly formed Wellsburg Church joined the Mahoning Association (thus avoiding excommunication)
    1823 Sept The two Pittsburgh Baptists groups appeared at the Redstone Association annual meetings (held in Pittsburgh) and argued as to which group should be accepted as the official Pittsburgh church. A commission is set up to investigate heresy charges brought against SR by the Winter faction.
    1823 Oct SR left Pittsburgh to accompany Alexander Campbell on a trip to KY
    1823 Oct 11 SR was "excluded from the Baptist denomination" about the time he arrived in KY; this was meant as an excommunication but was only valid within the Redstone Association
    1823 Oct 15-21 SR served as secretary to Alexander Campbell in his debate with Kentucky Presbyterian Rev. William L. McCalla
    1823 Fall Rigdon's disfellowshipped faction of the First Baptist Church "lost the meetinghouse "due to non-payment of ground rent."
    1823 Fall The Rigdon-led seceders from First Baptist Church and Walter Scott's Independent Church informally united, holding joint-meetings "every Sunday in the Allegheny County Court House;" the united group was loyal to the tenets of Alexander Campbell
    1823-25   SR took up work as a "journeyman tanner" (and eventually as a "currier") at a Pittsburgh tannery; he worked with his brother-in-law, Richard Brooks and/or William Brooks: SR may have purchased a part of this business with the proceeds of his June land sale to James Means
    1823-25   According to E. D. Howe, Rigdon "abandoned preaching and all other employment for the purpose of studying the bible"
    1824   Rev. David Phillips resigned from ministry of Peter's Creek Church
    1824 May SR wrote the Preface for the publication of Alexander Campbell's "A Debate on Christian Baptism..." with W. L. McCalla
    1824 Sum Campbell published his "A Debate on Christian Baptism..."
    1825 Aug 1 J. Harrison Lambdin died at age 27 (probably at Pittsburgh); if Lambdin had loaned or given a Spalding MS to his friend Rigdon, he was no longer alive to tell of that transaction

    1825 Dec? SR moved out of Pittsburgh and relocated in Bainbridge twp., Geauga Co., OH -- a new tannery had recently opened at that place and Rigdon evidently did piece-work leather finishing at home to pay for groceries. Although SR was reportedly called to Bainbridge by the small Bainbrigge Baptist congregation, he reportedly did no preaching during his first winter there.
    1826 Aug 24-27 SR preached a funeral service for deceased Baptist Rev. Warner Goodell in Mentor: he then attended the annual meeting of Mahoning Baptist ministers at Canfield, OH (evidently as an observer representing the adjacent Grand River Assoc.)
    1826 Nov 2 SR solemnized the marriage of Julia Giles and John G. Smith at Mentor -- apparently Rigdon became the new presiding elder for the Baptist congregation at Mentor about this time
    1826-27   SR reportedly was visited in Ohio by the young Joseph Smith, Jr. -- During this period Rigdon carried on periodic preaching for Baptist a congregation in northern Portage Co., Ohio -- he also visited Mentor, in northern Geauga Co. on occasion.
    1827 Spring SR apparently split his time between visits to Mentor and preaching obligations in northern Portage Co. Before summer he relocated his family from Bainbridge to Mentor, occupying a cabin on the Orris Clapp farm in that village.
    1827 Jul 17 Silas Engles died at age 46 (probably in or near Pittsburgh); if Engles had been aware of Lambdin, or anybody else, having once loaned Rigdon a Spalding MS, he was nolonger alive to tell of that transaction
    1827-28 Winter SR brings Baptist "teachers" Darwin Atwater and Zeb Rudolph from northern Portage Co. to Mentor, to attend his instructional classes -- the two students notice that Rigdon is frequently absent from that place (parts of Jan-Mar.)
    1828 Winter SR brings Baptist "teachers" Darwin Atwater and Zeb Rudolph from northern Portage Co. to Mentor, to attend his instructional classes -- the two students notice that Rigdon is frequently absent from that place (parts of Jan-Mar.)
    1828 Mar SR visits Adamson Bentley and Walter Scott at Warren, OH and accepts Scott's "ancient gospel" method of evangelizing -- it is possible that Rigdon asked for a second baptism (for the remission of sins) during this visit
    1828 Apr Adamson Bentley accompanied SR back to Mentor and assisted in implementing the "ancient gospel" within Grand River Associations congregations such as Kirtland and Mentor -- many new converts were brought into the "Reformed Baptist" ranks
    1829   Peter's Creek Church congregation adopted the Philadelphia Baptist Confession of Faith as a measure against recent inroads by Campbellism
    1829 Aug The Beaver (and subsequently Redstone) Baptist Association publishes an anathema against all members of the Mahoning Baptist Association in OH, breaking off fellowship -- some Redstone churches in Pennsylvania object to this action and separate from their parent organization to form the Washington Baptist Assoc.
    1830 Aug Dissolution of the Mahoning Baptist Association -- largely because of the disruptions caused by Alexander Campbell's reforms
    1830 Aug SR spoke before the annual meeting of the Mahoning Baptist Association, advocating a community of goods be established in the member churches as a major point in the restoration of Apostolic Christianity, similar to the experiment he was then conducting with members of his own congregation in OH; his suggested plan was demolished by Alexander Campbell's speech denouncing communal living for modern congregations
    1830 Nov 8 SR and wife baptized into Mormon Church by Oliver Cowdery


    Transcriber's Comments

    Detail from front cover of 1823 Redstone Baptist Association "Minutes"

    (under construction)

    Return to top of the page

    Sidney Rigdon Home Page   |   Rigdon's History   |   Mormon Classics E-Texts

    last revised Mar. 6, 2010